Issue 09: Is Nvidia Stock a Buy at 10 Times Earnings Without Huang?

· Members

NVDA$151.26 0.0% (+$0.00)

Nov 18 close

Since published on Nov 18 at $151.26 · SPY 0.0% · Edge 0.0 pts

Is Nvidia stock a buy without Jensen Huang? At $155.46 we think it is, bought in stages.

Nvidia trades at about half the S&P 500's multiple of expected earnings
AMD28.5x
Marvell20.2x
S&P 50017.7x
Broadcom17.6x
TSMC15.4x
Nvidia9.8x

Forward P/E: the November 17, 2026 closing price divided by the average analyst estimate of earnings per share for the next fiscal year. For Nvidia and Marvell that year ends in January 2028, for Broadcom in October 2027, and for AMD and TSMC in December 2027. Estimates were read on November 17 and had not yet changed for Nvidia's results.

Source: Yield Theory calculation from Yahoo Finance closes and consensus estimates; FactSet estimate for the S&P 500

Nvidia closed on November 17 at 9.8 times the profit analysts expect it to make next fiscal year. That ratio is the forward price-to-earnings ratio, or P/E: the share price divided by expected earnings per share. The S&P 500 trades at 17.7 times. Broadcom, which designs custom AI chips for the big cloud companies, trades at 17.6 times and AMD at 28.5.

Six weeks ago the same shares cost 15.1 times those earnings. Since then Nvidia has lost about $2 trillion of market value and the founder who ran it for 33 years.

What happened. On November 8 Jensen Huang, who had run Nvidia since 1993, told employees in an email that he had been unfaithful to his wife. The same day the board said it was investigating "recent reporting that founder and CEO Jensen Huang has been the target of a foreign intelligence effort," and that it had "no reason to believe that either national security or NVIDIA secrets were compromised." On November 12 Nvidia said he had resigned. It gave no reason that day.

Press reports, starting with The New York Times on October 29, allege a relationship with a former executive of Megaspeed, a buyer of Nvidia chips, whom US officials are reported to suspect of ties to Chinese intelligence. China's government has denied that, and no charge against Huang or Nvidia has been made public. On November 17 Huang said he had "made serious mistakes in my personal life" and would be "honored" to return as CEO if the board asked. Hours later Nvidia reported the largest quarter in its history. On the earnings call its chair, Harvey Jones, said Huang had resigned "after disclosure of personal behavior inconsistent with the company's code of conduct, standards, and cultural norms," and that the board "does not intend to reinstate Jensen as CEO."

This issue asks what the stock is worth if he never comes back. Whether he will is a separate question, covered on our free page about Huang's statement and the board's position. After Jones spoke, traders on Kalshi, a prediction market, put the chance of Huang being Nvidia's next permanent CEO at about 7%, down from 12% an hour earlier. We wouldn't buy the stock for that chance, and our numbers don't rely on it.

Our findings:

  • As much as $36 of the fall is specific to Nvidia. That is the gap between Tuesday's close and where the stock would be if it had moved with other chip stocks since Huang's first apology. Across all the shares, it comes to $873 billion.
  • The price needs only $8.81 of earnings. If Nvidia deserved the same multiple as the S&P 500, $155.46 would be justified by profit of $8.81 a share. Nvidia is on course to make about $9.60 this fiscal year, and analysts expect $15.86 next year.
  • On profits already earned, the stock is the cheapest it has been since 2013. It came close to this level twice, in 2015 and 2018. We look at what happened next.
  • Past exits like this one hurt for about a year. In five earlier cases, the stock trailed the S&P 500 by a median of 18.5 percentage points over 12 months. Nvidia has trailed it by 16.2 points in seven trading days.
  • We put a value and a probability on three scenarios. The price sits below two of them.

We end with three calls: on Nvidia, on the rivals that gained $319 billion of market value while it fell, and on the smaller companies that depend on Nvidia's balance sheet.

Why is Nvidia stock down 35%?

Three different things have hit the stock since its record close of $239.24 on October 6. Only the last one is about Huang.

Of the $84 a share Nvidia has lost, $31 has come since Huang's apology
Record close, Oct 6$239.24
AI sell-off, Oct 6 to Nov 3−$32.55= $206.69
After the midterms, Nov 3 to Nov 6−$20.05= $186.64
Since the apology, Nov 6 to Nov 17−$31.18= $155.46
Close, Nov 17$155.46
Closing prices per share. The legs are split at election day (November 3) and at the last close before Huang's apology email (November 6). The labels name the main news in each period. Other news moved the stock too, including the first press report about Huang on October 29.Source: Yield Theory calculation from Yahoo Finance closes
PeriodNvidiaChip stock indexS&P 500
October 6 to November 3−13.6%−19.8%−3.2%
November 3 to November 6−9.7%−11.4%−2.5%
November 6 to November 17−16.7%+2.7%−0.5%
Whole period−35.0%−27.0%−6.1%

The chip stock index is the PHLX Semiconductor index, which tracks 30 large US-listed chip companies.

October 6 to November 3: the whole AI trade sold off. Reuters put the fall in chip stocks down to "rising bets of an interest-rate hike and concerns over the cost of the AI buildout." Rates were the subject of last week's issue. Nvidia fell 13.6%, less than the 19.8% drop in the index.

November 3 to November 6: the midterms. Two days after the elections, on November 5, the chip index dropped 12.3% in a day. Reuters said chipmakers sank "on fears of tougher AI regulation" after Democratic wins in states where opposition to new data centers has grown. Issue 07 explains those votes. Over the three days Nvidia lost 9.7% and the index 11.4%.

November 6 to November 17: Huang. The apology email went out on Sunday, November 8, and the resignation followed on November 12. From the Friday close before the email to Tuesday's close, Nvidia fell 16.7%. The chip index rose 2.7%.

So until the apology, Nvidia was the safer chip stock. On November 6 it was 22.0% below its record, against 29.0% for the index. Everything it has lost relative to other chip stocks, it has lost in the seven trading days since.

How big is the Huang discount?

The stock has fallen $31.18 since November 6, the last close before the apology. Chip stocks rose 2.7% over those days. If Nvidia had moved with them, it would have closed on Tuesday at $191.66. It closed at $155.46. The gap is $36.20 a share.

That benchmark is generous to the gap. The chip index includes Nvidia's rivals, and some of their gains came from Nvidia's trouble. Measured against the S&P 500 instead, which slipped 0.5%, the gap is about $30 a share, or roughly $730 billion. We use the chip index because it strips out the chip-sector moves of those days, and we treat $36 as the top of the range.

Companies in this article

Keep reading

Members-only research

Members are reading this

The thesis, the numbers behind it, and what would break it. Full access is $39 a month.

Read the full research

Get a full issue free

Enter your email and we'll send you a complete Yield Theory issue, then the opening of each new one. Unsubscribe anytime.