Issue 08: Who Pays for a 5% Treasury? Stocks Hurt Most by Rising Rates

· Members

A December rate hike is priced. Who pays for it is not, and the answer is narrower than most investors think.

Homebuilders are the stocks hurt most by rising interest rates. On an average day this year, they have fallen about 2.7% for each 0.1-point rise in the 10-year Treasury yield that day (say, from 5.12% to 5.22%), about five times as much as the S&P 500.

Homebuilders move about five times as much as the S&P 500 when the 10-year yield rises
Lennar−3.24%
KB Home−3.19%
Toll Brothers−3.15%
D.R. Horton−3.02%
PulteGroup−2.73%
Homebuilders (iShares ETF)−2.68%
NVR−2.02%
Consumer discretionary−1.03%
Russell 2000 small caps−0.97%
Real estate−0.86%
Utilities−0.83%
Regional banks−0.68%
S&P 500−0.53%
Technology−0.52%
Financials−0.43%
Energy1.16%

Average same-day price move for each 0.1-point (10 bp) rise in the 10-year Treasury yield, 2026 trading days through November 13. Sectors are the Select Sector SPDR funds; regional banks are the SPDR S&P Regional Banking ETF.

Source: Yield Theory regression of Yahoo Finance closes on US Treasury 10-year yields

Utilities, real estate and small companies lose about 0.8% to 1%. Banks, the textbook winners from higher rates, have also fallen when yields rose. And the big tech stocks that drive the index have barely reacted to rates since July. They trade on AI.

We measured how every major US stock group has moved with the 10-year yield this year, day by day, because the next move is close: markets put the odds of a quarter-point Fed hike on December 9, to a range of 4% to 4.25%, at about 90%, and the 10-year closed at 5.12% on November 16. Our free explainer covers the decision itself.

Three calls follow from the screen.

  1. Utilities are the most mispriced rate trade. The sector's dividend yield is 2.4 points below the 10-year, the widest gap since at least 2001, yet they still fall when yields rise. Duke Energy and Southern Company are not growing dividends fast enough to justify it.
  2. Homebuilders are priced very differently. Lennar trades at its lowest price to book value since at least 2014, and KB Home sits in the bottom tenth of its range. Toll Brothers trades above 80% of its own history. If yields stay above 5%, the premium builders have further to fall.
  3. Banks are not a hedge. By their own filings, a full one-point rise in rates would add only 1% to 3% to the big banks' net interest income, and their shares have fallen on days when yields rose.

How we measured rate sensitivity

We took every trading day in 2026 through November 13, 214 days in all, and lined up each stock's daily price change against that day's change in the 10-year Treasury yield from the Treasury's daily yield curve. A regression, a standard way of finding the average relationship between two series, gives the typical move for each 0.1-point change in the yield. We call that the stock's rate sensitivity. Prices are Yahoo Finance closes.

Two caveats matter. First, sensitivity is an average, not a law. For homebuilders, the yield explains about a third to two-fifths of daily moves, a strong link for stock data. For tech, it explains almost none. Second, the numbers describe 2026. Since July, the S&P 500's sensitivity has fallen to −0.20% per 0.1 point, and tech's to roughly zero, because AI news has drowned out everything else. For both, the link is now too weak to lean on.

Since July 1Move per 0.1-point rise in the 10-yearHow closely it tracks yields (correlation, −1 to 1)
Homebuilders (iShares US Home Construction)−2.75%−0.64
NextEra Energy−1.34%−0.55
Utilities−0.76%−0.39
Real estate−0.78%−0.40
Regional banks−0.69%−0.31
S&P 500−0.20%−0.11
Technology+0.09%0.02
Energy+1.12%0.37

What happened the last time the 10-year neared 5%

Before this year, the last time was October 2023; in 2026 the 10-year first closed at 5% on September 15. In 2023 it climbed from 3.75% on July 19 to 4.98% on October 19, then fell back to 3.79% by December 27 as inflation cooled and the Fed signaled it was done raising rates. That round trip, up 1.23 points and down 1.19 points, is the best test of our sensitivities, because each leg is about twice the size of the moves in our scenarios.

GroupJul 19 to Oct 19, 2023: 10-year up 1.23 pointsOct 19 to Dec 27, 2023: 10-year down 1.19 points
Homebuilders (iShares US Home Construction)−18.0%+40.6%
Lennar−20.0%+42.7%
Toll Brothers−15.3%+49.9%
Regional banks−13.6%+30.4%
Real estate−14.6%+22.3%
Russell 2000 small caps−14.3%+21.5%
Utilities−11.5%+7.4%
NextEra Energy−27.3%+15.6%
Technology−7.3%+15.6%
S&P 500−6.3%+11.8%
Energy+11.2%−7.0%

Share price changes from Yahoo Finance closes. Yields are the Treasury's 10-year par yields, via FRED.

Three lessons carry over to today.

The broad order holds. Builders moved most, the S&P 500 least among the groups that fell, and energy moved the other way. Banks, real estate, small caps and utilities sat in between, as they do in 2026. Single stocks can stray far from their group, though: NextEra fell further than the builders.

Builders fall less than the math says, and rebound more. Applying the 2026 sensitivity to a 1.23-point rise implies a 33% fall for the homebuilder fund. It fell 18%. On the way back down it rose 41%, more than the 32% the same sensitivity implies. Once builders get cheap, buyers step in, and when rates turn, the rally is fast. We read the bear case prices below as more severe than likely, and we see the rebound as the bigger opportunity.

Companies in this article

Keep reading

Members-only research

Members are reading this

  • Aug 12, 2026

    Issue 05: NVIDIA Is Building the Credit Market for AI

    NVIDIA has found a way to turn knowledge of its own roadmap into a lower cost of capital for its customers. The result could move AI infrastructure from venture equity into private credit, insurance balance sheets and securitized debt.

  • May 30, 2026

    Start here: how Yield Theory approaches research

    Yield Theory is independent stock research for people investing their own money. Here is what's free, what members get, and three pieces to read first.

The thesis, the numbers behind it, and what would break it. Full access is $39 a month.

Read the full research

Get a full issue free

Enter your email and we'll send you a complete Yield Theory issue, then the opening of each new one. Unsubscribe anytime.