Why 9 in 10 Indian F&O Traders Lose Money: SEBI Data Explained

· Members

Last fiscal year, 7.86 million individual Indians traded equity futures and options. Together they lost about ₹91,685 crore, roughly $9.5 billion, and 87.7% of them finished the year down. That was a good year. It was 18% better than the one before, when India's market regulator, the Securities and Exchange Board of India (SEBI), had just begun a sweeping clampdown on retail speculation.

This piece explains how India became the world's largest derivatives market by contracts traded, who the traders are, and why buying short-dated options is a losing game with simple arithmetic behind it. It covers what SEBI's curbs changed, the allegations against Jane Street, and what all of it means for listed stocks like BSE, Angel One and CDSL. Our view is that the curbs trimmed the edges but left the core problem, expiry-day lottery tickets, in place. Rupee amounts are converted at about ₹96.8 per US dollar, the rate at the start of this month.

Watch it play outNine in ten traders paid for the game
7.86 million traders87.7% lost money₹91,685 crlost in one yearthe year before was worse

Last fiscal year, 7.86 million individuals traded Indian futures and options. Picture them as 100 people.

By year-end, 87.7% of them had lost money. That's about 88 of the 100.

Their money streamed out. Together they lost about ₹91,685 crore, roughly $9.5 billion.

And that was the good year. Losses were 18% smaller than the year before, when SEBI's clampdown began.

Source: SEBI's latest study of individual F&O traders

A few Indian terms first. A lakh is 100,000 and a crore is 10 million, so ₹1 lakh crore is ₹1 trillion. F&O means futures and options, the two derivatives that make up India's "equity derivatives segment". India reports by fiscal year, so "last fiscal year" here means the twelve months that ended about six months ago,.

Check the claimFour terms that make India's numbers readable

How big is India's options market?

By contract count, it's the biggest in the world. The National Stock Exchange (NSE) says it was the world's largest derivatives exchange last calendar year by contracts traded, on Futures Industry Association data, a title it has held for years. In one month early last year, SEBI noted, an Indian exchange traded more than 4.3 times as many contracts as the second-ranked exchange anywhere.

Keep reading

Members-only research

Members are reading this

The thesis, the numbers behind it, and what would break it. Full access is $39 a month.

Read the full research

Get a full issue free

Enter your email and we'll send you a complete Yield Theory issue, then the opening of each new one. Unsubscribe anytime.