Why Is the Indian Stock Market Falling? Foreign vs Domestic Money

· Members

Two years ago, India made up roughly a fifth of the MSCI Emerging Markets index, the benchmark most global funds use to divide money between developing countries. By the end of last month it was 10.65%. India's share has roughly halved, and it is now fourth in the index, behind Taiwan, South Korea and China.

Watch it play outIndia's slice of the emerging-markets index has roughly halved
MSCI Emerging MarketsIndiaTwo years ago: about a fifth10.65%end of last monthNow 4th, behind Taiwan, South Korea and China

Picture the MSCI Emerging Markets index, the benchmark global funds use to divide money between developing countries, as 100 dots.

Two years ago, India made up roughly a fifth of it.

Lift India's slice out of the index to see it on its own.

By the end of last month it was 10.65%. India's share has roughly halved.

India is now fourth in the index, behind Taiwan, South Korea and China.

This piece traces how that happened, from the market's peak two years ago to this year's record foreign selling. It shows the tug-of-war between foreign money leaving and Indian savers' money arriving, explains why earnings and valuations, not the economy, did the damage, and ends with what has to change for India to lead again. Dollar figures are as reported by each source; the rupee is trading near ₹96 per dollar.

Watch it play outThis year so far: India down, emerging markets up
startMSCI EMMSCI India+23.4%−14.9%$30.4Bforeign net selling

Start the year with the same amount, in dollars, in MSCI India and in MSCI Emerging Markets.

By last month-end, emerging markets were up 23.4%.

MSCI India was down 14.9% in dollars. The Nifty 50 was down 13.4% in rupees.

Meanwhile foreign investors have pulled a net $30.4 billion out of Indian stocks this year.

Source: NSE Indices factsheet; MSCI factsheets; NSDL

How far has the Indian stock market fallen since its peak?

The Nifty 50 is the National Stock Exchange's index of 50 large companies; the Sensex is BSE's index of 30. The Nifty closed at a record 26,216 two years ago. Within seven weeks it was almost 9% lower, as China's stimulus pulled money toward Chinese stocks and foreign investors sold a then-record of about ₹1 lakh crore (₹1 trillion; one lakh crore is one trillion rupees) in a single month.

Watch it play outChina's stimulus pulled foreign money out of India
Nifty 50Record: 26,216China₹1 lakh crore in a monthAlmost 9% lower

Two years ago the Nifty 50 closed at a record 26,216.

Then China's stimulus pulled money toward Chinese stocks.

Foreign investors sold a then-record of about ₹1 lakh crore of Indian stocks in a single month.

Within seven weeks of its record, the Nifty was almost 9% lower.

The Nifty recovered in rupee terms, rising 10.5% last year and touching a new high of 26,358.25 in the first days of this one. Then the year turned. War involving Iran, which broke out about seven months ago, pushed oil above $100 a barrel, US 10-year Treasury yields climbed to 5.29% by the start of this month, and the rupee hit a record low of 96.96 per dollar five months ago. The Nifty ended last month down 13.43% for the year and closed at 22,422 a week ago, a two-year low and about 15% below its record from the start of the year (a fall from peak like this is a drawdown).

Companies in this article

Keep reading

Members-only research

Members are reading this

The thesis, the numbers behind it, and what would break it. Full access is $39 a month.

Read the full research

Get a full issue free

Enter your email and we'll send you a complete Yield Theory issue, then the opening of each new one. Unsubscribe anytime.