Bank Nifty Is at a Record but Cheap. Which Banks Gain From RBI Hikes?
· Members
The Nifty Bank index closed at a record, but it is a record in price, not in valuation. At 1.85 times book value, it is cheaper than on 91% of trading days since December 2021. RBI rate hikes help bank profits, but by less than the 11.70% rally since the October hike suggests.
A record high on a below-average valuation
61,575.90Nifty Bank, record closePrevious record close 61,550.80, in February
+11.70%Since the RBI's October hikeFrom the close the day before
1.85xPrice to book valueAverage since December 2021: 2.45x
₹89,856 crForeign buying of Indian shares this monthA record month on NSDL's data
Source: NSE index data; NSDL
Our margin math puts the gain at roughly 1% to 3% of a year's profit for each 25 basis point hike, once deposit costs catch up. So this rally is mostly money coming back to a sector that had become cheap, not a re-rating that higher rates have earned. That leaves room for more, but it also makes stock choice matter more. Most of the remaining discount sits in the private banks. The state-owned banks that led the rally now trade above their own history.
The index closed at 61,575.90 in the latest session, a hair above its February record close, after climbing 14.08% in 13 sessions from its late-October low. Foreign investors have bought a net ₹89,856 crore (about $9.5 billion at ₹94 to the dollar) of Indian shares so far this month, more than in any full month on NSDL's records, after selling financial stocks for most of the year. And the RBI is expected to raise rates again in early December; our free page on whether the RBI will increase the repo rate again covers that call.
This issue works out what the hike is actually worth to each of the 11 largest listed banks, what it costs them on their bond holdings, how each one is valued against its own history and its peers, and where the index goes in a bull, base and bear case. Then we rank the 11. Two findings stand out. The large private bank with the most to gain from higher rates on our numbers still trades below its own valuation history. And two of the rally's biggest winners now trade more than 20% above theirs, while one of them is growing deposits at little more than a third of the pace of its loans.
Why did Bank Nifty hit a record?
Foreign money, mostly. Since the day before the RBI's hike, the Nifty Bank index is up 11.70% and the Nifty 50 11.04%. For the year, Nifty Bank is up 3.35% while the Nifty 50 is down 3.21%, so banks have been one of the few places a broad Indian portfolio made money in 2026.
The scale is unusual. Foreign investors' record inflow this month compares with ₹66,135 crore in December 2023, the previous biggest month on NSDL's records. On the exchanges' provisional data, foreign institutions bought a net ₹84,167 crore in cash shares this month while domestic institutions, mainly mutual funds and insurers, sold a net ₹52,608 crore (as compiled by Moneycontrol and Groww). On these figures, domestic funds have been selling into the rally rather than driving it.
Banks are the natural first stop for that money. Financial services make up 37.13% of the Nifty 50 and 30.07% of everything foreign investors own in Indian shares, on NSDL's sector data. Foreign investors had sold about ₹1.15 lakh crore of financial stocks from March to May and another ₹9,517 crore in October, and financials fell from 31.82% of their Indian holdings at the end of 2025 to 30.07% at the end of October. That left them holding less of the sector just as oil fell and the rupee firmed, which our page on the Sensex rally explains. NSDL's sector split for November isn't out yet, so we can't say how much of this month's money went to banks.
State-owned banks led the rally; Axis and IDFC First lagged
PNB+29.19%
Union Bank+22.06%
ICICI Bank+18.04%
Bank of Baroda+16.10%
HDFC Bank+14.77%
Kotak Mahindra Bank+14.42%
SBI+13.74%
Federal Bank+13.13%
Canara Bank+12.37%
Nifty Bank index+11.70%
Axis Bank+7.56%
IDFC First Bank−0.32%
Price change from the close on the day before the RBI's October hike to the latest close.
Source: NSE bhavcopy and index closing data
HDFC Bank matters most for the index, at 18.18% of Nifty Bank, followed by ICICI Bank (14.99%), Kotak Mahindra Bank (11.28%), Axis Bank (9.97%) and SBI (9.94%). HDFC Bank has risen 14.77% since the hike but is still down 17.63% for the year, so the index's biggest stock remains well below where it started 2026 even with the index at a record.
Is Bank Nifty expensive at a record high?
No. On NSE's own figures, the index trades at 1.85 times book value, the balance-sheet value of the banks' equity, against an average of 2.45 since December 2021. A year ago it was 2.22. The low was 1.62, at the end of September, a few weeks before this rally began.
Bank valuations fell for two years; only state-owned banks are above average
Price to book value at each quarter end, from NSE's daily index data. Nifty Bank was 1.65x at the end of September; the low of 1.62x came on the second-last trading day of September.Source: NSE index data
Part of that discount is deserved, because banks earn less on their equity than they did. Dividing the index's price-to-book ratio by its price-to-earnings ratio gives its implied return on equity (RoE), the profit banks make on each rupee of shareholders' money: about 13.6% now, against about 17.5% in March 2024. Rate cuts squeezed margins, as the next section shows. But the price-to-earnings ratio, which already reflects today's lower profits, is also below its average: 13.61 against 16.03 since December 2021, and 16.47 a year ago. So banks are cheap on what they earn now, not only on their book value.
They are cheap against the rest of the market too, which is itself cheap. The Nifty 50 trades at 3.10 times book, below 93% of days since December 2021. Bank valuations relative to the Nifty are lower still: Nifty Bank's price-to-book is 0.60 times the Nifty's, against an average of 0.64, and its price-to-earnings 0.66 times, against 0.74.
Index
Price to book now
Average since Dec 2021
Cheaper than
At the start of the 2022 hiking cycle
Nifty Bank
1.85x
2.45x
91% of days
2.69x
Nifty Private Bank
2.17x
2.48x
83% of days
2.66x
Nifty PSU Bank
1.29x
1.17x
32% of days
0.78x
Nifty 50
3.10x
3.80x
93% of days
4.36x
NSE daily data. "Cheaper than" is the share of trading days since December 2021 with a higher price-to-book ratio.
The last column is the useful comparison. In the 2022 to 2023 hiking cycle, the PSU Bank index rose 42.28% from the last close before the first hike to the day of the last one, but it started at 0.78 times book. Today it starts at 1.29 times, above its own average, so that kind of re-rating is mostly used up. Private banks start this cycle cheaper than they started the last one.
How does an RBI rate hike affect bank stocks?
Through the net interest margin (NIM), the gap between what a bank earns on loans and what it pays for deposits, as a share of its assets. A hike lifts both sides, but at different speeds:
Loans linked to MCLR, a rate each bank sets from its own funding costs, reset on each loan's anniversary, usually once a year.
Fixed-rate loans don't reprice until they are repaid.
Savings and current accounts (CASA) usually pay the same rate whatever the RBI does.
Term deposits reprice only when they mature and the customer renews.
So for a while a hike widens margins at banks with many repo-linked loans and many CASA deposits, until maturing term deposits catch up. Cuts do the opposite, and the last cycle shows how much. Between February 2025 and August 2026 the RBI cut the repo rate by 125 basis points. Its own bulletin shows rates on outstanding loans fell 76 basis points while rates on outstanding term deposits fell only 53. That gap came straight out of margins.
Margins fell most at Axis, Kotak and Bank of Baroda over the past year
NIM a year agoNIM latest quarter
12345%0
3.27%3.16%
HDFC BankNIM a year ago3.27%NIM latest quarter3.16%
4.30%4.18%
ICICI BankNIM a year ago4.30%NIM latest quarter4.18%
3.73%3.36%
Axis BankNIM a year ago3.73%NIM latest quarter3.36%
4.54%4.31%
KotakNIM a year ago4.54%NIM latest quarter4.31%
2.96%2.94%
SBINIM a year ago2.96%NIM latest quarter2.94%
2.96%2.74%
Bank of BarodaNIM a year ago2.96%NIM latest quarter2.74%
2.60%2.58%
PNBNIM a year ago2.60%NIM latest quarter2.58%
2.50%2.55%
CanaraNIM a year ago2.50%NIM latest quarter2.55%
2.67%2.86%
Union BankNIM a year ago2.67%NIM latest quarter2.86%
3.06%3.32%
Federal BankNIM a year ago3.06%NIM latest quarter3.32%
HDFC BankICICI BankAxis BankKotakSBIBank of BarodaPNBCanaraUnion BankFederal Bank
Net interest margin for the quarter to September this year and a year earlier, as each bank reports it. HDFC Bank's is on total assets; SBI, PNB and Bank of Baroda are whole-bank figures. Banks define the ratio differently, so compare each bank with itself.Source: Bank investor presentations and results, quarter to September
There is a complication for the private banks in the current quarter. In the quarter to September, banks raised large foreign-currency deposits from non-resident Indians under an RBI swap window: ICICI Bank alone mobilised about $18 billion. These FCNR(B) deposits lifted reported deposit growth, but they earn little at first and were on the books for only part of that quarter. HDFC Bank says they added 4 percentage points to its deposit growth; Axis Bank says they took 11 basis points off its margin, whose NIM would have been 3.47% without them.
That is why ICICI Bank expects margins to dip again before they rise. "The full impact of this on the average balance sheet will come in Q3, and we will see a further moderation in margins, offset a little bit by the rate hike," its finance team said on its results call. "But then from Q4, I would expect margins to come back in a healthy way." For investors the timing matters: the hike's benefit will show most clearly in results for the quarter to March, published in April and May, not in January's.
Which banks gain most from the rate hike?
The ones with the most loans tied to a market benchmark and the most deposits that don't reprice. On the banks' own disclosures, the share of loans linked to the repo rate or another external benchmark ranges from about a third at IDFC First Bank to about two thirds at PNB.
How much of each bank's loan book reprices with the repo rate
PNB (repo 56.5, T-bill 8.8)65%
Axis Bank62%
Kotak Mahindra Bank*60%
ICICI Bank57%
Union Bank*54%
Canara Bank*53%
SBI (repo 32, T-bill 17)49%
Federal Bank45%
Bank of Baroda*38%
IDFC First Bank*32%
Share of loans linked to the repo rate, Treasury bill yields or other external benchmarks, latest quarter. * Stated by management on the results call rather than in a published breakdown. HDFC Bank says about 70% of its book is floating rate, "mostly repo", but publishes no split.
Source: Bank investor presentations and earnings call transcripts
To turn that into money, we estimated what each 25 basis point hike adds to a bank's yearly profit. The method is simple, and it errs on the cautious side:
Loans: benchmark-linked loans earn 0.25 points more for a full year. MCLR loans are left out, though some will reprice.
Deposits: CASA deposits don't change. Half of each bank's term deposits mature and renew within the year, at a rate either 0.125 or 0.25 points higher.
Profit: the gain is taxed at 25% and compared with the bank's profit over the last four quarters.
Bank
Benchmark-linked loans
Before deposits reprice
Deposits reprice half the hike
Deposits reprice fully
PNB
65%
+7.8%
+5.3%
+2.8%
Axis Bank
62%
+5.8%
+4.2%
+2.6%
HDFC Bank
60% (our assumption)
+4.7%
+3.3%
+1.9%
Union Bank
54%
+5.5%
+3.6%
+1.7%
Kotak Mahindra Bank
60%
+4.1%
+2.9%
+1.7%
SBI
49%
+5.6%
+3.5%
+1.4%
IDFC First Bank
32%
+7.1%
+4.2%
+1.4%
ICICI Bank
57%
+3.6%
+2.5%
+1.3%
Canara Bank
53%
+6.9%
+4.1%
+1.2%
Federal Bank
45%
+5.2%
+3.0%
+0.7%
Bank of Baroda
38%
+5.8%
+3.0%
+0.2%
Our estimates, per 25 basis point hike, as a share of profit after tax over the four quarters to September. Standalone figures from each bank's latest results. HDFC Bank doesn't publish a split; 60% is our assumption from its "about 70% floating, mostly repo" description. SBI includes its Treasury bill-linked loans.
In rupees, the first-year lift before deposits reprice is largest at SBI (about ₹6,380 crore before tax) and HDFC Bank (about ₹4,830 crore on our assumption), followed by ICICI Bank, PNB, Axis Bank and Canara Bank at roughly ₹1,800 crore to ₹2,600 crore each.
Two things stand out. First, banks with a lot of term deposits relative to their benchmark-linked loans keep little of the gain. Bank of Baroda drops from 5.8% to 0.2% because only 38% of its loans move with the repo rate. Second, ICICI Bank's percentages look small only because it is so profitable: the same rupee gain is a smaller share of a bigger profit.
What management says lines up with the math:
Bank
What management said about the hike
HDFC Bank
The hike "should largely be factored in by December"; margin "neutral to positive", and "it is at the bottom" (call)
ICICI Bank
Margins dip in the December quarter, then "from Q4 ... come back in a healthy way" (call)
Axis Bank
Loans reprice late in the quarter, so the benefit shows from the March quarter; "sequentially, we should be able to show an improvement" (call)
Kotak Mahindra Bank
"Full impact will be felt in Q4"; it "takes about 3 months to kind of bleed right through" (call)
Federal Bank
Benchmark-linked loans "will reprice ahead of deposits, which will reprice as they mature"; keeps its 5 to 6 basis points a quarter margin guidance (call)
IDFC First Bank
Margin of about 5.80% by the March quarter, from 5.58%, with 7 basis points net from the hikes, assuming one more (presentation)
The hike will play a "positive constructive role in the NIM and ROA" (call)
Now put it next to the share prices. If the RBI raises twice more and deposits catch up fully, our numbers add between about 0.5% and 6% to bank profits. Nifty Bank has already risen 11.70% since the hike. The rally has priced in more than the rate hikes alone can deliver, which is why the rest of this issue turns to valuation.
What did bank stocks do in the last hiking cycle?
The cheapest banks won, not the most rate-sensitive ones. From the last close before the RBI's first hike in May 2022 to the close on the day of its last hike in February 2023, the repo rate rose from 4.00% to 6.50%. Over that stretch every big bank except Kotak Mahindra Bank beat the Nifty 50's 4.70% gain.
In the 2022 to 2023 cycle, the cheap state-owned banks gained most
Union Bank+88.34%
IDFC First Bank+53.15%
Bank of Baroda+49.00%
PNB+47.22%
Federal Bank+38.92%
Canara Bank+28.68%
Axis Bank+19.85%
HDFC Bank+17.83%
ICICI Bank+15.94%
Nifty Bank index+14.86%
SBI+11.97%
Nifty 50+4.70%
Kotak Mahindra Bank−0.50%
Price change from the close before the first hike (May 2022) to the close on the day of the last (February 2023), adjusted for bonuses and splits.
Source: NSE bhavcopy and index closing data
The biggest winners started the cycle cheap. The PSU Bank index traded at 0.78 times book when the hikes began, and Union Bank, Bank of Baroda and PNB all rose by around half or more. Kotak went nowhere, and even after the cycle it traded at 4.15 times book at the end of March 2023, the highest of the 11. Starting valuation mattered more than how fast a bank's loans repriced.
That is the lesson for today, and it points away from the state-owned banks. The PSU Bank index starts this cycle at 1.29 times book, not 0.78. Another 42% gain at today's book value would take it to about 1.83 times, close to the 1.86 peak it reached in June 2024, the highest since at least December 2021. The private banks are the ones starting cheap this time.
What's the catch for bank stocks?
There are three: bond losses, a scramble for deposits and, further out, bad loans. Only the second is big enough to change our numbers.
Bond losses are real but small
When interest rates rise, bond prices fall, and banks hold a lot of government bonds. Under the RBI's investment rules, losses on bonds in the "available for sale" (AFS) book go to a reserve in shareholders' equity "without routing through the Profit & Loss Account", so they reduce book value and capital, not reported profit. Bonds held to maturity aren't marked to market at all. Only the trading book hits profit directly.
Bank
AFS book
Modified duration
Loss per 0.25 point rise in yields
Share of net worth
SBI
₹2,85,600 crore
2.82 years
₹2,013 crore
0.38%
PNB (AFS and trading)
₹1,34,895 crore
3.90 years
₹1,315 crore
0.93%
Bank of Baroda
₹61,032 crore
3.17 years
₹484 crore
0.35%
Union Bank (SLR bonds)
₹44,791 crore
4.25 years
₹476 crore
0.37%
Book sizes and durations from each bank's latest investor presentation; SBI's AFS book is our estimate from its disclosed share of the domestic book. Losses are our calculation: book × duration × 0.25%. Canara Bank doesn't disclose its duration.
Modified duration is roughly the percentage a bond's price falls when its yield rises one point. Our bond duration calculator lets you test other moves. Even PNB, the most exposed, loses under 1% of net worth per quarter-point rise in yields. And the 10-year government bond yield has risen only about 0.1 points since the day before the hike. SBI did book a mark-to-market loss of about ₹1,275 crore on bonds valued through profit in the September quarter, its management said on the call, but its bond book is not the main risk.
Loans are outrunning deposits
This is the real catch, and it decides whether the hike lands in the "half" or the "fully" column of our table. Almost every big bank is growing loans faster than deposits. A bank in that position has to compete for deposits, and competing means paying more.
Bank
Loan growth
Deposit growth
Gap
Union Bank
18.53%
6.87%
11.66 points
ICICI Bank (excluding FCNR)
24.1%
17.0%
7.1 points
Canara Bank
19.46%
13.13%
6.33 points
Kotak Mahindra Bank (excluding FCNR)
19%
13%
6 points
SBI
17.84%
12.27%
5.57 points
PNB
14.7%
9.9%
4.8 points
IDFC First Bank
30.1%
25.9%
4.2 points
Federal Bank
21.7%
18.6%
3.1 points
Axis Bank
23%
21%
2 points
Bank of Baroda
18.3%
16.4%
1.9 points
HDFC Bank (including FCNR)
16.3%
18.8%
Deposits ahead
Year-on-year, to the end of September, from each bank's results. ICICI and Kotak publish growth excluding the special foreign-currency deposits; HDFC Bank says they added about 4 points to its deposit growth.
Union Bank's deposits are growing at little more than a third of the pace of its loans. It and Canara Bank, which has the lowest CASA ratio of the 11 at 29.0%, are the most likely to see deposit costs rise faster than our central case. The banks with the most CASA, IDFC First Bank (47.6%), SBI (38.32%) and Kotak (38.2%), are the best protected.
Bad loans are not a problem yet
Gross bad loans range from 1.04% of loans at Kotak to 2.55% at PNB, and credit costs in the latest quarter were mostly between 0.2% and 0.5% of loans. Higher rates do raise borrowers' EMIs, by about ₹768 a month on a ₹50 lakh home loan per hike, as our free page shows. A cycle of 50 to 75 basis points is small next to the 250 basis points of 2022 to 2023. We would worry if inflation stays above 6% into 2027 and the RBI keeps going.
How do the 11 banks compare on valuation?
On their own history, the private banks are mostly cheaper than usual and the state-owned banks mostly dearer. The table compares each bank's price-to-book ratio today with its average at the end of each of the last four financial years.
Bank
Price (₹)
Price to book
Own average
Versus own average
P/E
RoE
NIM
CASA
HDFC Bank
816.50
2.15x
2.43x
−11%
16.5
13.5%
3.16%
31.6%
ICICI Bank
1,585.00
3.16x
3.03x
+4%
20.8
16.6%
4.18%
36.1%
Axis Bank
1,342.40
1.91x
1.98x
−4%
15.1
13.3%
3.36%
36.0%
Kotak Mahindra Bank
494.20
3.37x
3.53x
−5%
31.1
11.7%
4.31%
38.2%
Federal Bank
362.00
2.18x
1.41x
+54%
18.4
13.6%
3.32%
32.0%
IDFC First Bank
81.30
1.42x
1.30x
+9%
23.8
8.5%
5.58%
47.6%
SBI
1,090.50
1.91x
1.86x
+3%
11.9
about 17%
2.94%
38.3%
Bank of Baroda
270.20
1.01x
1.15x
−12%
7.6
about 14%
2.74%
36.4%
PNB
144.59
1.17x
0.94x
+24%
7.9
about 15%
2.58%
36.6%
Canara Bank
132.40
1.06x
1.08x
−2%
6.1
about 18%
2.55%
29.0%
Union Bank
205.60
1.22x
1.01x
+21%
7.4
about 17%
2.86%
34.9%
Prices are the latest NSE closes. Price to book uses standalone book value per share at the end of September. "Own average" is the price-to-book ratio at the end of March in 2023, 2024, 2025 and 2026, adjusted for bonuses and splits; HDFC Bank's excludes March 2023, before its merger with HDFC Ltd. P/E uses standalone profit for the four quarters to September. RoE is the bank's reported annualised figure for the private banks and our estimate (trailing profit over average book value) for the state-owned banks.
A few adjustments change the picture:
SBI, Kotak and HDFC Bank own valuable subsidiaries. Their share prices include those businesses, but standalone book value and profit don't. Kotak's consolidated book value is ₹196 a share, so on that basis it trades at 2.52 times book, not 3.37.
SBI's profit includes a one-off. A ₹7,288 crore pre-tax gain on selling part of its fund management arm sits in the last four quarters. Without it, and assuming 25% tax because SBI didn't disclose the post-tax figure, its P/E would be about 12.7.
Bank of Baroda's profit includes a one-off charge of ₹5,680 crore before tax in the June quarter. Excluding it, its P/E would be about 6.1, level with Canara Bank as the lowest of the 11.
The state-owned banks are cheap on P/E, between about 6 and 12 times. That has been true for years: the PSU Bank index's P/E has averaged 8.3 since December 2021, on NSE's data. So a low P/E alone isn't a reason to buy them. The useful test is against their own history, and on that test PNB and Union Bank have already re-rated.
Three scenarios for Bank Nifty over the next year
The index's value comes down to two things: how fast the banks' book value grows and what multiple investors pay for it. At 1.85 times book, the index's book value works out to about 33,284 index points (61,575.90 divided by 1.85). Book value grows by RoE times the share of profit banks keep, which is about 86% for the index, since its dividend yield of 1.02% at a P/E of 13.61 implies a payout of about 14%.
Our calculation from the latest close of 61,575.90 and NSE's price to book of 1.85x. 2.45x is the average since December 2021.Source: NSE; Yield Theory calculation
The sensitivity is lopsided. Each 0.1 change in the price-to-book ratio moves the index by about 3,700 points, or 6%. Each extra point of RoE adds only about 0.9 points of book growth, roughly 500 index points. Even two more hikes at the top of our deposit-adjusted range add only about 6% to profit, which lifts RoE by under one point. So the index's path over the next year depends mostly on whether investors keep paying more for bank earnings, and that depends on foreign flows and on margins turning up when they're due to.
Our ranking: which bank stocks still have room?
We rank the 11 on what the rate cycle can add, how much the share price already reflects, and what could go wrong. This is a view on risk and reward over about a year, using only the evidence in this issue.
Rank
Bank
Why it's here
Main risk
1
Axis Bank
Below its own valuation history at 1.91x book; 62% of loans move with the repo rate; the biggest margin squeeze of the big banks to reverse; lagged the rally at +7.56%
RoE of 13.3%; foreign-currency deposits weigh on the December quarter
2
HDFC Bank
2.15x book against a 2.43x post-merger average; about 70% floating-rate loans, mostly repo; management says margins are at the bottom
RoE of 13.5%, well below ICICI Bank's 16.6%; no published loan split
3
SBI
P/E of about 12.7 excluding the one-off, RoE about 17%; 49% of loans tied to repo or Treasury bills; guides to a margin of at least 3%
Largest bond book; loans growing 5.6 points faster than deposits
4
ICICI Bank
The highest RoE of the big banks at 16.6%; clear guidance for margins to recover from the March quarter
3.16x book is above its own history; margins dip first
5
Bank of Baroda
Cheapest on book at 1.01x, 12% below its own history; P/E about 6.1 excluding the one-off
Only 38% of loans repo-linked, so little to gain from hikes
6
Kotak Mahindra Bank
High CASA at 38.2%; about 60% repo-linked; NIM 4.31%
RoE of 11.7%; 2.52x consolidated book is not cheap for that return
7
Canara Bank
P/E 6.1 and RoE about 18%, in line with its own history
Lowest CASA (29%) and lowest disclosed CET1 capital ratio (12.80%) of the 11
8
Federal Bank
Margin rising, from 3.06% to 3.32% in a year, with 5 to 6 basis points a quarter guided
54% above its own valuation history; small gain from hikes once deposits reprice
9
PNB
The biggest rate leverage on our numbers, and management expects 7 to 9 basis points on margin
Up 29% since the hike and 24% above its own history; highest gross bad loans (2.55%)
10
Union Bank
RoE about 17% and margin up to 2.86%
Deposits growing at little more than a third of the pace of loans; 21% above its own history
11
IDFC First Bank
The only bank to quantify the hike's effect, and the highest CASA (47.6%)
RoE of 8.5% at 23.8 times earnings
Axis Bank is our first pick because it combines the three things this cycle rewards. It has one of the highest shares of repo-linked loans, it lost the most margin in the cuts (from 3.73% to 3.36%) and so has the most to win back, and it trades below its own history while the market has bid up almost everything else. It is also the second-highest gainer in our deposit-adjusted model. The main risk is that its RoE of 13.3% stays low because of credit costs (0.45% last quarter), in which case the discount is deserved.
HDFC Bank and SBI follow for different reasons. HDFC Bank is the index's biggest stock and still down 17.63% for the year; at 2.15 times book, against 2.43 since its merger, it needs only a margin recovery, which management says has started, to close part of the gap. We have not found a published reason for the fall this year, so we don't assume one. SBI is the cheapest large bank on earnings, has a large share of loans tied to market rates and the strongest CASA of the state-owned banks, but its deposit growth lags.
At the bottom are the banks the market has already rewarded. PNB and Union Bank have the most rate leverage among the state-owned banks, but they trade 24% and 21% above their own history after the biggest gains in the sector. Union Bank's deposit gap makes it the most likely to disappoint if deposit costs rise. Federal Bank's re-rating is earned by its margin gains but leaves little room. IDFC First Bank has improving margins, but its 8.5% RoE is the lowest of the 11 by a wide margin, and it trades at 23.8 times earnings.
What would change our view
Deposit costs. The RBI's monthly lending and deposit rate data show the average rate on new loans and new deposits. If deposit rates rise as fast as loan rates over the next two releases, our net numbers fall towards the right-hand column, and high-CASA banks (Kotak, SBI, IDFC First) move up the ranking.
A bigger or longer hiking cycle. A 50 basis point hike or a peak above 6.25% means more margin for repo-heavy banks but bigger bond losses and more strain on borrowers. That helps the banks with the most repo-linked loans, but hurts those with long bond portfolios, such as PNB and Union Bank, with durations of 3.90 and 4.25 years.
Foreign flows reversing. This rally is built on a record month of foreign buying. A reversal would push the index's price-to-book back towards September's low of 1.62, our bear case.
Margins in the March quarter. HDFC Bank, ICICI Bank, Axis Bank and Kotak all point to a recovery in the March quarter. If it doesn't show up in results published in April and May, the "margins have bottomed" case fails, and so does our top two.
Oil above $100. That would bring back the inflation pressure the RBI is fighting and make a longer cycle likely.
Our read
Bank stocks are at a record because foreign money came back to the cheapest large sector in a cheap market, not because the RBI's hikes have transformed bank profits. On our numbers, each 25 basis point hike adds 1% to 3% to a year's profit once deposits catch up. That is helpful but modest, and the rally has already priced in more than that.
The record still doesn't make banks expensive. The index trades at 1.85 times book and 13.6 times earnings, both below their averages since December 2021, and below the market on both measures. Our base case is that Nifty Bank grows with its book value, about 12% over a year, with a bull case near 79,000 if margins recover and foreign buying continues, and a bear case near 58,500 if deposit costs outrun loan yields.
Within the sector, the opportunity has moved. The state-owned banks did the heavy lifting in the last cycle and in this rally, and some now trade well above their own history while their deposits lag. The large private banks, Axis Bank and HDFC Bank above all, are where valuations are still below their own norms and where the hike's benefit should be clearest from the March quarter.
For someone holding a Bank Nifty index fund, our base case means a return close to the growth in book value, about 12% over a year, plus a dividend yield of about 1%. HDFC Bank and ICICI Bank make up a third of the index, so the fund rides mostly on them. Picking individual banks adds value only if you pick the ones whose valuations haven't already run, and on our numbers that means the private banks first.
How we built this
Prices are NSE closes for November 16, 2026 from the exchange's bhavcopy and index files; the day before the RBI hike is October 6, 2026; the October low was the close of October 27, 2026. Index price-to-book, P/E and dividend yields are NSE's daily figures from December 1, 2021 to November 16, 2026; the 2022 to 2023 cycle runs from the close of May 2, 2022 to February 8, 2023. Index weights are from the latest Nifty Bank factsheet. Foreign flows are NSDL's daily reports through November 16, 2026 and its fortnightly sector data to October 31, 2026; exchange provisional flows for November 2 to 16, 2026 are as compiled by Moneycontrol and Groww. Bank figures are standalone, for the quarter ended September 30, 2026, from each bank's investor presentation, results filing and earnings call between October 16 and November 7, 2026, with trailing profit over the four quarters to September 30, 2026. Book value per share is as reported or computed from net worth and shares outstanding; March price-to-book ratios use closes of March 31, 2023, March 28, 2024, March 28, 2025 and March 30, 2026, adjusted for HDFC Bank's 1:1 bonus and the Kotak and Canara Bank splits. Bond rules are from the RBI's Master Direction on investment portfolios (2023). The repo reset rule and easing-cycle transmission figures are from RBI circulars and the RBI Bulletin for October 2026. All sensitivity and scenario numbers are our own calculations from these inputs, as described in each table.
Go deeper
Will RBI increase the repo rate again?: our free page on the December decision, the inflation numbers behind it and what another hike adds to a home loan EMI.
India's inflation hit a record-low 0.25% in October 2025 and the RBI cut rates by 125 basis points. A year on it is 6.09% and rates are rising again. Here's what both swings meant for bank, NBFC, consumer and auto stocks.
Brent fell 8.7% in one session after the US midterms. We work through what each $10 does to India's import bill, inflation and the rupee, then rank IndiGo, the oil marketers, paints, tyres, city gas, ONGC and Reliance across three war scenarios.
The thesis, the numbers behind it, and what would break it. Full access is $39 a month.