Coal India vs Mahanadi Coalfields: Which Is Cheaper After the IPO?
· Members
Coal India is the cheaper share, and if you own it we would keep it. At the ₹136 IPO price, Mahanadi Coalfields (MCL) costs 8.2 times the past year's earnings and Coal India costs 7.2. Take MCL and the other listed stakes out of Coal India's price, and the rest goes for about 6 times.
The IPO puts a price on a third of Coal India
8.2xMahanadi Coalfields at ₹1369.1x once one-off income is removed
7.2xCoal India at ₹391.55NSE close, November 17, 2026
₹131MCL inside each Coal India share0.97 MCL shares, 34% of the price
6.0xThe rest of Coal IndiaAfter listed stakes and IPO cash
Source: MCL red herring prospectus; Coal India results; NSE; Yield Theory calculation
Cheaper is not the same as better. MCL is Coal India's best business: it mines the cheapest coal in the group, pays out more of its profit, and carries a much smaller wage bill. The rest of Coal India has the weaker mines and most of the 2.4 lakh workers whose pay deal expired in June.
Which share is the better one to own depends on three things that the prospectus and the broker notes don't put numbers on:
What October's coal auctions are worth. Buyers paid 140% over the list price for Coal India's auctioned coal last month, against 38% last year. We work out what each 10 points adds to each company's profit.
What the wage deal will cost. Coal India has started setting money aside, at about a third of what the last deal cost.
What each share is worth. We give bull, base and bear values for both, and the price at which we'd rather own MCL.
What does the Mahanadi Coalfields IPO price say about Coal India?
It says a third of Coal India's share price is now backed by a business with its own public price.
Coal India is selling 10% of MCL and keeping 90%, according to the red herring prospectus of November 13, 2026 (RHP). MCL has 661.84 crore shares, so Coal India keeps 595.65 crore of them. Coal India itself has 616.27 crore shares. Divide one by the other and each Coal India share carries a claim on 0.967 MCL shares.
At ₹136, the top of the price band, that claim is worth ₹131.45. Coal India closed at ₹391.55 on the NSE on November 17, 2026. So MCL alone accounts for 33.6% of the price.
Two more pieces already trade. Coal India listed Bharat Coking Coal (BCCL) in January 2026 and its mine planning arm, CMPDI, in March 2026, and still owns 90% and 85% of them. At their November 17 closes of ₹30.91 and ₹186.45, those stakes are worth ₹21.02 and ₹18.36 per Coal India share.
Then there is the IPO money. The whole ₹8,981 crore (₹9,001 crore at ₹136, less a discount on employees' shares) goes to Coal India, not to MCL. This is an offer for sale: the owner sells existing shares and the company raises nothing. That is ₹14.57 per Coal India share before tax and costs.
Take out the listed pieces and ₹206 of Coal India's price is left
Coal India share price₹391.55
MCL stake (90%) at ₹136−₹131.45= ₹260.10
BCCL stake (90%)−₹21.02= ₹239.08
CMPDI stake (85%)−₹18.36= ₹220.72
IPO cash−₹14.57= ₹206.15
Everything else₹206.15
Per Coal India share. Listed stakes at NSE closes on November 17, 2026; MCL at the top of its price band; IPO cash before tax and issue costs.Source: MCL red herring prospectus; NSE bhavcopy; Yield Theory calculation
What is the "everything else"?
It is five unlisted coal companies and the parent. South Eastern Coalfields (SECL), Northern Coalfields (NCL), Central Coalfields (CCL), Western Coalfields (WCL) and Eastern Coalfields (ECL) together mined 514 million tonnes in the year to March 2026 (FY26), which is two thirds of the group's coal.
The market values all of that at ₹206 a share, or about ₹1.27 lakh crore. On our sum of each company's reported profit, those businesses earned ₹19,187 crore in FY26 and ₹21,209 crore in the 12 months to September 2026. That is 6.6 times last year's profit and 6.0 times the trailing figure, meaning the latest 12 months.
There is a second gap inside the first. MCL's profit of the past 12 months includes ₹1,530 crore of income that the RHP itself calls "non-recurring": interest on tax refunds and old liabilities written back. Strip it out, taxed at MCL's FY26 rate of 25.5%, and MCL earned ₹9,865 crore, or ₹14.91 a share. On that cleaner number, ₹136 is 9.1 times earnings.
So a buyer in the IPO pays 9.1 times for MCL, while a buyer of Coal India pays 6.0 times for the rest. That is a 52% premium for the best mines.
What if the rest were valued like MCL?
Put MCL's 8.2 multiple on the rest of the group and Coal India would be worth ₹467 a share, 19% above its price. That is not a target. Holding companies usually trade below the sum of their parts, because shareholders can't reach a subsidiary's cash without the parent's board. The rest of Coal India also deserves a lower multiple than MCL, for reasons the next sections put numbers on.
From November 27, 2026, the day MCL is due to list, every rupee it trades above ₹136 makes the rest of Coal India look cheaper still.
Is Coal India cheap against its own history and its peers?
Against its own history, no. It is close to its usual price. Against other state-owned companies and other coal miners, yes.
Coal India earned ₹50.46 a share in FY26 and ₹24.94 in the six months to September 2026, against ₹21.19 in the same half a year earlier, according to its results filed on October 29, 2026. That makes ₹54.21 for the past 12 months, and a price to earnings ratio of 7.2. It paid ₹26.50 a share in dividends for FY26, a dividend yield of 6.8%.
The annual report for 2025-26 gives the same two ratios at each March year-end. Over the eight years from FY19 to FY26, the median was 6.7 times earnings and a 7.6% yield.
Coal India is priced near its eight-year norm, not below it
0510152025FY17FY18FY19FY21FY23FY24FY25Now7.2Price to earnings (times)6.8Dividend yield (%)FY1612.99.4FY1719.86.8FY1825.05.8FY198.45.5FY205.28.6FY216.312.3FY226.59.3FY234.211.4FY247.25.9FY256.96.7FY268.95.9Now7.26.8
At each March 31 year-end, and at the November 17, 2026 close on trailing earnings. The high ratios of FY17 and FY18 came from a profit slump: employee costs rose 27% in FY18, the year of the last-but-one wage deal.Source: Coal India Integrated Annual Report 2025-26; NSE; Yield Theory calculation
The share has fallen, though. It is 18.7% below its highest close of the year, ₹481.65 on June 4, 2026, and it lost 3.0% in the two sessions to November 17 as the IPO price band came out. Buyers in March 2026 paid 8.9 times earnings. Buyers today pay 7.2 times for a company whose half-year earnings per share are up 17.7%.
Against everything else on the exchange, it is cheap in the way state-owned commodity companies usually are.
Measure, November 17, 2026
Price to earnings
Dividend yield
Coal India
7.2
6.8%
Coal India, eight-year median
6.7
7.6%
MCL at ₹136
8.2
9.3%
Nifty PSE index (state-owned companies)
9.8
3.4%
Nifty 50
20.7
n/a
NMDC (iron ore)
8.5
n/a
Bukit Asam (Indonesia, coal)
11.4
n/a
Yancoal (Australia, coal)
18.3
n/a
The index figures are from the NSE's daily index file. The three miners are the peers in MCL's RHP, at November 11, 2026 prices. MCL's 9.3% is last year's dividend over the IPO price; this year's buyer gets less.
Brokers were positive before the price band. After the September quarter results, Nuvama had a buy rating and a ₹501 target, Elara a buy and ₹522, Motilal Oswal a buy and ₹450, and Prabhudas Lilladher an accumulate and ₹465, as Business Standard reported on October 30, 2026. All four sit above our base case of ₹372, which assumes a wage deal as costly as the last one.
Which Coal India subsidiaries make the money?
Two of them: MCL and NCL. Together they made 69% of the group's FY26 profit from 47% of its coal.
MCL is a third of the profit. It made 34.4% of FY26 profit and 31.7% of the latest half, from 28.4% of the coal. Its mines are shallow and mechanised: the RHP shows it producing 30.34 tonnes per worker shift against the group's 12.65. That is why it keeps 47.45% of revenue as operating profit and the group keeps 29.65%. Per tonne, though, NCL earns more.
MCL is not where the growth is. Its profit rose 6.7% in the half. SECL's nearly doubled and ECL swung from a loss to a profit. On our sum, the rest of the group's trailing profit is 10.5% above its FY26 level, and MCL's is 2.9% above. Half-year gains from a low base shouldn't be projected forward, and MCL's own half-year profit is up about 13% on a year earlier once one-off income is taken out of both halves. But a buyer of Coal India is not buying a shrinking remainder.
The weak units are small. ECL and BCCL together lost ₹838 crore in FY26. That is 2.7% of group profit. They are a drag, not a danger.
Who really pays Coal India's dividend?
MCL does, for about half of it.
MCL declared ₹8,400 crore of dividends for FY26, all of it to Coal India, according to the dividend table in the RHP. Coal India in turn paid its own shareholders ₹26.50 a share, which is ₹16,331 crore. So MCL's cheque covered 51% of Coal India's payout.
That link changes after the IPO. One tenth of every MCL dividend now goes to MCL's new shareholders. On last year's figures that is ₹840 crore a year that no longer reaches Coal India, or ₹1.36 per Coal India share, about 5% of its dividend. In earnings, Coal India gives up 10% of MCL's profit: ₹1.74 a share, or 3.4% of FY26 earnings.
It could go further. Listed companies must have at least 25% of their shares in public hands, and the secretary of the government's disinvestment department, Arunish Chawla, told CNBC-TV18 on November 16, 2026 that Coal India can sell a further 15% as it moves to 75%. At a 75% stake, Coal India would give up ₹4.34 a share of last year's earnings, 8.6%, in return for the sale proceeds.
Dividend measure
MCL
Coal India
Dividend for FY26
₹12.69 a share
₹26.50 a share
Share of profit paid out
78.5%
52.5%
Yield on today's price
9.3% at ₹136
6.8% at ₹391.55
Declared so far for FY27
₹7.78, all to Coal India before listing
₹15.75 in two interim dividends
MCL's higher payout is the main reason to prefer it. But the 78.5% was a wholly owned subsidiary passing cash up to its parent, and nothing in the RHP commits MCL to keep that rate as a listed company. The only binding floor is the government's rule for state-owned companies: 30% of profit or 4% of net worth, whichever is higher. You can test payout rates with our dividend coverage calculator.
Has the coal cycle turned?
Prices have turned sharply. Volumes have not, and that is the part to watch.
First, the terms. Coal India sells about nine tenths of its coal under long-term fuel supply agreements, mostly to power plants, at a list price it sets itself, called the notified price. The other tenth goes through e-auctions, where buyers bid above that price. The gap is the e-auction premium, the most cyclical part of the group's profit.
That premium is why profits fell. MCL earned a premium of ₹802 on each auctioned tonne in FY24, ₹405 in FY25 and ₹275 in FY26, according to the RHP. Its auction premium income fell from ₹1,833 crore to ₹728 crore over those two years. For the whole group, the premium averaged 38% over the notified price in FY26, on Coal India's monthly auction filings.
Auction buyers paid 140% over the list price in October
0255075100125150%AprMayJunJulAugSepOct140%Coal India e-auction premium over notified price, 202638%FY26 averageApr51%38%May36%38%Jun42%38%Jul41%38%Aug59%38%Sep94%38%Oct140%38%
Premium over the notified price in Coal India's single-window e-auctions, by month of booking. May's figure is as reported by Energywatch; the rest are from Coal India's filings.Source: Coal India monthly e-auction filings
The premium was not even across the group. NCL's coal went for 283% over its notified price in October, MCL's for 181%, SECL's for 162%. BCCL, which mines coking coal for steel and not thermal coal for power, got 29%.
October's auction premium, by subsidiary
NCL283%
MCL181%
SECL162%
Coal India, whole group140%
ECL132%
CCL109%
WCL108%
BCCL29%
Premium over the notified price for coal booked in e-auctions in October 2026. April to October 2026: NCL 138%, ECL 81%, SECL 76%, MCL 67%, WCL 55%, CCL 45%, BCCL 30%, group 68%.
Source: Coal India e-auction filing for October 2026
Why volumes are the weak spot
Coal India sold far more coal than it mined this year. From April to October 2026 it produced 388.2 million tonnes, up 0.7%, and dispatched 454.6 million, up 9.2%, according to its production filing of November 1, 2026. The 66 million tonne gap came out of its stockpiles, which fell from 130.28 million tonnes on April 1 to 66.58 million on September 30.
MCL shows the same pattern. Its production fell 4.2% over the seven months to 108.4 million tonnes while its dispatches rose 8.7% to 131.8 million, with a record 20.8 million tonnes in October. Its own stock fell from 44.22 million tonnes to 20.11 million in the first half.
A company can't sell from stock forever. For high prices to become higher profit next year, the mines have to produce more after the monsoon. If they don't, dispatches fall back to what is mined, and coal that might have gone to auction goes to power plants at the notified price. The government wants plants to hold 55 million tonnes by March 2027, the Bloomberg report said, which is good for demand and less good for the share of coal that earns a premium.
What do higher auction prices add to profit?
Less than the headline premium suggests, and more for Coal India than for MCL.
Start with MCL. In FY26 it booked 26.49 million tonnes in auctions at an average premium of ₹275 a tonne, which was 27% over the notified price. That implies a notified price of about ₹1,018 a tonne for the coal it auctions. So each 10 points of premium is worth about ₹102 a tonne, or ₹270 crore a year of revenue on last year's auction volume.
Not all of that is profit. Royalties and other levies took 12.5% of MCL's revenue in FY26 and tax took 25.5% of its pre-tax profit. After both, each 10 points of premium adds about ₹176 crore to MCL's yearly profit. That is 1.6% of FY26 profit.
Do the same sum for Coal India, with its average fuel supply price of ₹1,443.52 a tonne standing in for the notified price, and each 10 points adds about ₹789 crore. Coal India gains more because its coal sells for more per tonne and it keeps less of each rupee as profit to begin with. A thinner margin makes any price rise matter more.
Each 10 points of auction premium, held for a year
MCL
Coal India
Auction volume, FY26
26.49 million tonnes
83.83 million tonnes
Extra profit after levies and tax
₹176 crore
₹789 crore
As a share of FY26 profit
1.6%
2.5%
Per share
₹0.27
₹1.28
October alone shows the scale. MCL booked 43.12 lakh tonnes at a 181% premium. On our implied notified price that is about ₹795 crore of premium in one month, more than the ₹728 crore it earned in all of FY26. After levies and tax it would be about ₹518 crore.
Don't multiply that by 12. Auctioned coal is lifted over the following months, so October's prices show up in the December and March quarters. And one month says little about a year: from April to September, MCL's premium averaged about 36% on our working from the filings.
Even a 100% premium held all year on last year's volume adds about ₹1,283 crore, 12% of MCL's profit. That is a real gain, but it would only take profit back to roughly where it was in FY24. The auction market can repair MCL's earnings. It can't transform them, because nine tenths of the coal still goes out at the notified price.
What will the Coal India wage deal cost?
This is the number that separates the two shares.
Coal India's non-executive workers are paid under a five-year National Coal Wage Agreement. The eleventh one expired on June 30, 2026. The twelfth will apply from July 1, 2026 whenever it is signed, the RHP says, and the committee that negotiates it had not even been formed by late September, the trade site Indian PSU reported on September 23, 2026.
Coal India has started to set money aside. Note 4 to its September quarter results says it booked an estimated ₹499.29 crore for the three months from July to September 2026. That is about ₹2,000 crore a year, or 4.3% of its FY26 employee cost of ₹46,425 crore.
Now compare that with last time. The eleventh agreement gave a minimum 19% rise in pay and a 25% rise in allowances. It took nearly two years to conclude. When it was finally signed, Coal India said it had set aside ₹9,252.24 crore for the 21 months from July 2021 to March 2023, as Business Standard reported on May 22, 2023. That works out to ₹5,287 crore a year, which was 13.7% of the employee cost in the year before the deal took effect, on the annual report's ten-year table.
So today's provision is about a third of what the last deal cost, in proportion. The last cycle started the same way. Of that ₹9,252 crore, ₹5,870 crore was booked in the single quarter to March 2023, the Hindu BusinessLine reported at the time. For the 18 months before that, Coal India had been setting aside about ₹560 crore a quarter, much like today's ₹499 crore.
If the twelfth deal costs the same share of the wage bill as the eleventh, the bill for Coal India is about ₹6,360 crore a year. After tax that is ₹4,738 crore, or 15.2% of FY26 profit. For MCL, whose employee cost was ₹4,719 crore, the same sum gives ₹647 crore a year: ₹482 crore after tax, or 4.5% of its profit.
A wage deal like the last one costs Coal India three times as much of its profit
MCLCoal India
51015202530%0
15.4%27.6%
Employee cost, share of revenueMCL15.4%Coal India27.6%
1.4%4.8%
Deal as provided so far, share of profitMCL1.4%Coal India4.8%
4.5%15.2%
Deal like the last one, share of profitMCL4.5%Coal India15.2%
Employee cost, share of revenueDeal as provided so far, share of profitDeal like the last one, share of profit
FY26 figures. Wage costs are yearly and after tax at 25.5%. MCL's share of the group's provision is our estimate, split by employee cost. "Like the last one" means 13.7% of the wage bill, which is what the 2021 agreement cost.Source: MCL red herring prospectus; Coal India results and annual report; Business Standard; Yield Theory calculation
Can Coal India raise prices to pay for it?
It did last time, and that rise skipped MCL's coal.
Days after the wage deal was concluded in May 2023, Coal India raised its notified prices by 8%. It expected ₹2,703 crore of extra revenue over the ten months left in that year, the Economic Times reported on May 31, 2023. That is about ₹3,244 crore a year, or 61% of the yearly wage cost.
But coal is graded from G1 to G17 by the heat it gives off, and the rise applied only to grades G2 to G10, the better coal. MCL's coal averages grade G13, according to the CRISIL industry report in its RHP.
That cuts both ways for MCL. It can't count on a price rise to cover its wage bill, but if one ever reaches its grades the effect is large. A 1% rise on the 181 million tonnes MCL sold under supply agreements in FY26, at ₹1,354 a tonne, is worth ₹245 crore before tax. A 2.6% rise would pay for a wage deal like the last one.
For Coal India the timing is worse. The wage cost builds from July 2026, and a price rise, on the last pattern, comes only after the deal is signed.
Wage outcome for Coal India, per year
Cost before tax (₹ crore)
Hit to earnings per share, on top of the one quarter already booked
As provided so far
1,997
₹1.81
Like the last deal, with a price rise that recovers 61%
2,458 net
₹2.37
Like the last deal, no price rise
6,360
₹7.08
The last row is ₹7.08 on trailing earnings of ₹54.21. To cancel it with auction prices alone, the premium would have to stay 55 points higher for a full year.
Nearly all of this lands on the cheap part of Coal India. On our numbers, a deal like the last one with no price rise would cut the rest of the group's trailing profit by about 18%, after allowing for the provision already booked. Its multiple would go from 6.0 to 7.3. MCL's would go from 9.1 to 9.6. The gap narrows, but it doesn't close.
What is the ₹31,228 crore Odisha question?
It is the largest risk in the RHP, and owning Coal India instead of MCL doesn't get you out of it.
In 2004 Odisha passed a law taxing coal-bearing land at 15% of the yearly value of the coal. The Orissa High Court struck it down on December 5, 2005, and the state's appeal is still before the Supreme Court. For years that looked like a dead issue.
Then, in July and August 2024, the Supreme Court ruled in a separate case that states may tax mineral-bearing land, may raise demands going back to April 1, 2005, and must collect them in 12 yearly instalments from April 1, 2026, with no interest or penalty for the period before the ruling. The government auditor, the CAG, sets this out in comments printed in the RHP. It adds that Odisha has not passed a new law, "but possibility of a new Act or revival of old Act with possibility of demands in future cannot be ruled out", and that Coal India's own legal department worked out the possible outflow at ₹31,227.80 crore.
MCL's reply, printed alongside, is that it has no present obligation, has received no demand and can't estimate one reliably. The sum is not provided for and not in its contingent liabilities.
Here is what the figure means if it ever became payable in full. It is ₹47 for each MCL share, 35% of the company's value at ₹136. Spread over 12 years it is about ₹2,600 crore a year, or ₹3.93 a share, against a dividend of ₹12.69 last year. Nearly a third of the dividend would be spoken for.
Coal India owns 90% of MCL, so the same claim is ₹45.60 for each Coal India share, 12% of its price. In rupees per share the exposure is almost identical, because each Coal India share holds almost one MCL share. As a share of what you paid, the MCL buyer carries three times as much. We treat it as a low-odds, high-cost risk: no demand exists and the state would have to legislate first.
The RHP has smaller items of the same kind. Contingent liabilities, meaning disputed claims it has not set money aside for, stood at ₹12,513 crore on September 30, 2026, against ₹8,506 crore six months earlier. One customer, Andhra Pradesh's power generator, owed 51% of receivables. And Coal India sets MCL's prices, its wages and a fee of ₹20 a tonne that MCL pays it, which can change "at Coal India Limited's sole discretion". None of this is new to Coal India's shareholders. It was all inside the group already.
What are the two shares worth? Bull, base and bear
Each case sets four things for the year to March 2028 (FY28): the auction premium, the coal sold, the wage outcome, and the multiple the market pays. We start from trailing earnings without MCL's one-off income, and for Coal India we also take out the 10% of MCL's profit that now belongs to other shareholders. The premiums differ because the starting points do: MCL's low-grade coal earned a 27% premium in FY26 and the group's earned 38%. Each case moves both by a similar number of points.
Mahanadi Coalfields, from a clean trailing profit of ₹9,865 crore
Bear
Base
Bull
Average auction premium
27%
50%
80%
Coal sold (million tonnes)
205
220
232
Wage deal
Like the last one
Like the last one
As provided so far
Interest and other income
₹300 crore lower
₹150 crore lower
Unchanged
Profit after tax (₹ crore)
8,484
9,675
11,185
Earnings per share
₹12.82
₹14.62
₹16.90
Multiple
7.0
8.2
9.5
Value per share
₹90
₹120
₹161
Dividend at a 78.5% payout
₹10.1
₹11.5
₹13.3
Value plus one year's dividend, against ₹136
-26.4%
-3.3%
+28.1%
Coal India, from clean trailing earnings of ₹52.36 a share
Bear
Base
Bull
Average auction premium
38%
60%
90%
Coal sold
2% lower
3% higher
6% higher
Wage deal
Like the last one, no price rise
Like the last one, price rise recovers 61%
As provided so far
Earnings per share
₹41.73
₹51.61
₹57.28
Multiple
6.7
7.2
8.5
Value per share
₹280
₹372
₹487
Dividend at a 52.5% payout
₹21.9
₹27.1
₹30.1
Value plus one year's dividend, against ₹391.55
-22.9%
+1.9%
+32.1%
Neither share is a bargain on our base case. Both come out a little below today's price, and a year of dividends brings both back to about where they started.
Coal India comes out ahead in all three cases, by three to five points. That is a small edge, and it sits inside our assumptions. Most of it comes from one fact: the one-off income is 10% of MCL's trailing profit and only 3% of Coal India's. On clean earnings MCL costs 9.1 times and Coal India 7.5.
The multiple is our judgment. The bear multiples are near Coal India's eight-year median of 6.7. The base case keeps each share at today's headline multiple. The bull case gives Coal India the 8.5 to 9 times it traded at in March 2026 and MCL a premium to that. If you think MCL deserves 9.5 times in a normal year, its base value is ₹139, not ₹120.
The wage deal is "like the last one" in both the base and bear cases. That is deliberate. The provision looked just as small at this stage last time. For Coal India the two cases differ by whether a price rise follows. For MCL, whose grades were skipped last time, we assume no price rise in either.
For Coal India, the wage deal moves earnings more than the auction market
Pick an average auction premium and a wage outcome
Coal India earnings per share₹42.6₹47.3₹47.8₹43.7₹48.4₹49.0₹45.4₹50.1₹50.6₹49.2₹53.9₹54.5₹55.6₹60.3₹60.9
−21.4%−12.7%−11.8%−19.4%−10.7%−9.6%−16.2%−7.6%−6.6%−9.2%−0.6%+0.6%+2.6%+11.3%+12.4%below Past 12 months, as reportedbelow Past 12 months, as reportedbelow Past 12 months, as reportedbelow Past 12 months, as reportedbelow Past 12 months, as reportedbelow Past 12 months, as reportedbelow Past 12 months, as reportedbelow Past 12 months, as reportedbelow Past 12 months, as reportedbelow Past 12 months, as reportedbelow Past 12 months, as reportedabove Past 12 months, as reportedabove Past 12 months, as reportedabove Past 12 months, as reportedabove Past 12 months, as reported
Past 12 months, as reported₹54.2
₹42.6₹60.9
Our calculation, with coal volumes unchanged, after removing MCL's one-off income and the 10% of MCL's profit sold in the IPO. Each 10 points of premium is worth ₹1.28 a share. The 47% trailing premium is our estimate.Source: Coal India results and e-auction filings; MCL red herring prospectus; Yield Theory calculation
At the past year's 47% premium and a deal like the last one with a price rise, Coal India earns about ₹48.40 a share. At ₹391.55 that is 8.1 times, almost the same as MCL's headline 8.2. Put the same wage deal through MCL's clean earnings and ₹136 is 9.6 times.
Two ways to value MCL
On earnings, MCL's base value is ₹120. On dividends, it is higher. Our base case pays ₹11.5 a share. If the market asks the 7.6% yield that Coal India has given at the median since FY19, that dividend supports ₹151. At a 9% yield it supports ₹128.
₹136 sits between MCL's earnings value and its dividend value
Earnings view, bear to bull₹90 to ₹161
Dividend view, 9% to 6.8% yield₹128 to ₹169
Base value on earnings₹120
IPO price₹136
Base dividend at a 7.6% yield₹151
₹80₹100₹120₹140₹160₹180
Our FY28 scenarios. The dividend view divides the base case dividend of ₹11.5 a share by the yield investors might ask.Source: Yield Theory calculation
That is why we call ₹136 fair and not cheap. An income buyer who trusts the payout can justify it. A buyer who looks at clean earnings pays about 13% over our base value.
What will Coal India do with the IPO money?
Spend it on new businesses, not hand it back.
Coal India's management said on November 16, 2026 that the proceeds will help fund its diversification into coal gasification, critical minerals and renewable energy, Business Standard reported. The plan is about ₹1 trillion (₹1 lakh crore) over five years, with roughly ₹30,000 crore of it as equity. A Coal India executive told CNBC-TV18 in May 2026 that ₹66,000 crore of it is for gasification.
This is the main reason the rest of Coal India is cheap, and it is a fair one. MCL sends 78.5% of its profit out as dividends. Coal India pays 52.5% and puts much of the rest into projects with no earnings record. ₹14.57 a share of IPO cash is only worth ₹14.57 if it earns a decent return.
At MCL's multiple of 8.4 times FY26 profit, NCL would be worth about ₹89,800 crore and SECL about ₹40,100 crore. Add MCL's ₹90,010 crore and three subsidiaries come to ₹2.2 lakh crore, which is 91% of Coal India's entire market value of ₹2.41 lakh crore. Holding company discounts rarely vanish, but each listing makes the gap harder to ignore.
Coal India or Mahanadi Coalfields: which should you own?
On our numbers, Coal India by a small margin for total return, and MCL only if income is the whole point.
Which share fits which investor
Coal India at ₹391.55
7.2 times trailing earnings, 6.0 for the part that isn't listed
Base value ₹372, bear ₹280, bull ₹487
Base dividend ₹27.1 a share, a 6.9% yield
Carries most of the wage risk and the new spending
Our pick for total return
vs
MCL at ₹136
8.2 times trailing earnings, 9.1 without one-off income
Base value ₹120, bear ₹90, bull ₹161
Base dividend ₹11.5 a share, an 8.4% yield
Small wage bill, but a third of its value exposed to the Odisha claim
Fair for income, our pick below ₹120
If you already own Coal India, you own 0.97 MCL shares for each share you hold. Selling Coal India to buy MCL swaps the cheap part for more of the dear part. One Coal India share buys 2.88 MCL shares at ₹136. Your base case dividend income would rise from ₹27.1 to about ₹33, a gain of 22%, and you would give up your claim on everything priced at 6 times earnings. We wouldn't make that trade. A base case return near zero is not a reason to sell an income holding, either: on our numbers Coal India still pays about ₹27 a share a year, 6.9% of today's price. Applying with new money in the shareholder quota, the slice of the IPO reserved for Coal India's shareholders, is a different matter, and our free page covers it.
If you want income and own neither, MCL at ₹136 is reasonable. An 8.4% base case yield beats Coal India's 6.9%, and the wage deal can't do much damage to it. Expect the share price to drift, not climb.
If you want the best return for the risk, we prefer Coal India at this price. It is ahead in each of our three cases, and it has more ways to be pleasantly surprised: a price rise, more listings, a tight auction market.
Price would change the order. The IPO band is ₹129 to ₹136. At ₹129 the two shares come out level on our base case, so a final price near the bottom of the band, or a weak listing, removes Coal India's edge. Below about ₹120 after listing, MCL would trade under our base value and yield 9.6%, and we would prefer it outright. And if Coal India rose above about ₹415 with MCL still at ₹136, the base case would tip towards MCL.
What would change our view
The wage provision. If Coal India's December quarter results, due around the end of January 2027, raise the ₹499 crore quarterly estimate sharply, our bear case becomes the base case.
A notified price rise. One limited to the better grades helps Coal India and not MCL. One that reaches grade G13 would lift MCL's value more than anything in the auction market: each 1% is ₹245 crore before tax.
Production after the monsoon. If monthly output stays flat while stocks are this low, our base case volumes are too high for both.
Odisha. A new land tax law, or a Supreme Court ruling on the old one, would hurt both shares and MCL more.
MCL's listing price. Above ₹151, MCL would be priced beyond our dividend value, which would make Coal India the cheaper way to own the same mines by a wider margin.
Our read
At ₹136, a third of each Coal India share is backed by a business priced at 8.2 times earnings, and the rest goes for 6 times.
That gap is partly deserved. The rest of the group carries the wage bill, the weaker mines and a spending plan with unproven returns. But on our numbers it is wider than those justify, and Coal India comes out slightly ahead of MCL in a bad, normal or good year.
MCL is the better business and Coal India is the better price. At ₹136 we would hold Coal India, apply for MCL only for its income, and switch our preference if MCL falls to about ₹120.
How we built this
Share prices are NSE closes for November 17, 2026. MCL figures are from its red herring prospectus of November 13, 2026: restated accounts to September 30, 2026, the dividend table, risk factors, the CAG's comments and the CRISIL industry report. The ₹136 price is the top of the band announced on November 16, 2026, as reported by the Economic Times and Business Standard. Coal India figures are from its results of October 29, 2026, its presentations of April 27 and October 30, 2026, its annual report for 2025-26, and its e-auction and production filings to October 2026.
The calculations are ours. Our piece-by-piece valuation adds up each unlisted subsidiary's own profit, which differs slightly from consolidated profit. Clean earnings remove interest on tax refunds and liabilities written back, taxed at 25.5%. Auction sensitivities use a notified price implied by MCL's FY26 premium, levies at 12.5% of revenue, and Coal India's average supply price as a stand-in for its notified price. Wage cases scale the last agreement's cost to today's wage bill, and MCL's share of the provision is estimated from employee cost. Volume changes are valued at each company's average operating profit per tonne. Multiples are our judgment, and no scenario figure is a forecast by either company.
At its reported IPO price, Reliance's stake in Jio alone would be worth about 43% of the parent's ₹16.3 lakh crore market value. We value each part of Reliance and look at debt, succession and why the stock has lagged.
Bank Nifty hit a record, yet at 1.85 times book it is cheaper than on 91% of days since 2021. What RBI rate hikes add to bank profits, and 11 banks ranked.
The thesis, the numbers behind it, and what would break it. Full access is $39 a month.