Coal India vs Mahanadi Coalfields: Which Is Cheaper After the IPO?

· Members

Coal India is the cheaper share, and if you own it we would keep it. At the ₹136 IPO price, Mahanadi Coalfields (MCL) costs 8.2 times the past year's earnings and Coal India costs 7.2. Take MCL and the other listed stakes out of Coal India's price, and the rest goes for about 6 times.

The IPO puts a price on a third of Coal India
8.2xMahanadi Coalfields at ₹1369.1x once one-off income is removed
7.2xCoal India at ₹391.55NSE close, November 17, 2026
₹131MCL inside each Coal India share0.97 MCL shares, 34% of the price
6.0xThe rest of Coal IndiaAfter listed stakes and IPO cash
Source: MCL red herring prospectus; Coal India results; NSE; Yield Theory calculation

Cheaper is not the same as better. MCL is Coal India's best business: it mines the cheapest coal in the group, pays out more of its profit, and carries a much smaller wage bill. The rest of Coal India has the weaker mines and most of the 2.4 lakh workers whose pay deal expired in June.

Which share is the better one to own depends on three things that the prospectus and the broker notes don't put numbers on:

  • What October's coal auctions are worth. Buyers paid 140% over the list price for Coal India's auctioned coal last month, against 38% last year. We work out what each 10 points adds to each company's profit.
  • What the wage deal will cost. Coal India has started setting money aside, at about a third of what the last deal cost.
  • What each share is worth. We give bull, base and bear values for both, and the price at which we'd rather own MCL.

For the IPO itself (dates, the grey market premium, the quota rules, whether to apply), see our free page: Mahanadi Coalfields IPO: is the 9% dividend real?

What does the Mahanadi Coalfields IPO price say about Coal India?

It says a third of Coal India's share price is now backed by a business with its own public price.

Coal India is selling 10% of MCL and keeping 90%, according to the red herring prospectus of November 13, 2026 (RHP). MCL has 661.84 crore shares, so Coal India keeps 595.65 crore of them. Coal India itself has 616.27 crore shares. Divide one by the other and each Coal India share carries a claim on 0.967 MCL shares.

At ₹136, the top of the price band, that claim is worth ₹131.45. Coal India closed at ₹391.55 on the NSE on November 17, 2026. So MCL alone accounts for 33.6% of the price.

Two more pieces already trade. Coal India listed Bharat Coking Coal (BCCL) in January 2026 and its mine planning arm, CMPDI, in March 2026, and still owns 90% and 85% of them. At their November 17 closes of ₹30.91 and ₹186.45, those stakes are worth ₹21.02 and ₹18.36 per Coal India share.

Then there is the IPO money. The whole ₹8,981 crore (₹9,001 crore at ₹136, less a discount on employees' shares) goes to Coal India, not to MCL. This is an offer for sale: the owner sells existing shares and the company raises nothing. That is ₹14.57 per Coal India share before tax and costs.

Take out the listed pieces and ₹206 of Coal India's price is left
Coal India share price₹391.55
MCL stake (90%) at ₹136−₹131.45= ₹260.10
BCCL stake (90%)−₹21.02= ₹239.08
CMPDI stake (85%)−₹18.36= ₹220.72
IPO cash−₹14.57= ₹206.15
Everything else₹206.15
Per Coal India share. Listed stakes at NSE closes on November 17, 2026; MCL at the top of its price band; IPO cash before tax and issue costs.Source: MCL red herring prospectus; NSE bhavcopy; Yield Theory calculation

What is the "everything else"?

It is five unlisted coal companies and the parent. South Eastern Coalfields (SECL), Northern Coalfields (NCL), Central Coalfields (CCL), Western Coalfields (WCL) and Eastern Coalfields (ECL) together mined 514 million tonnes in the year to March 2026 (FY26), which is two thirds of the group's coal.

The market values all of that at ₹206 a share, or about ₹1.27 lakh crore. On our sum of each company's reported profit, those businesses earned ₹19,187 crore in FY26 and ₹21,209 crore in the 12 months to September 2026. That is 6.6 times last year's profit and 6.0 times the trailing figure, meaning the latest 12 months.

There is a second gap inside the first. MCL's profit of the past 12 months includes ₹1,530 crore of income that the RHP itself calls "non-recurring": interest on tax refunds and old liabilities written back. Strip it out, taxed at MCL's FY26 rate of 25.5%, and MCL earned ₹9,865 crore, or ₹14.91 a share. On that cleaner number, ₹136 is 9.1 times earnings.

So a buyer in the IPO pays 9.1 times for MCL, while a buyer of Coal India pays 6.0 times for the rest. That is a 52% premium for the best mines.

What if the rest were valued like MCL?

Put MCL's 8.2 multiple on the rest of the group and Coal India would be worth ₹467 a share, 19% above its price. That is not a target. Holding companies usually trade below the sum of their parts, because shareholders can't reach a subsidiary's cash without the parent's board. The rest of Coal India also deserves a lower multiple than MCL, for reasons the next sections put numbers on.

From November 27, 2026, the day MCL is due to list, every rupee it trades above ₹136 makes the rest of Coal India look cheaper still.

Is Coal India cheap against its own history and its peers?

Against its own history, no. It is close to its usual price. Against other state-owned companies and other coal miners, yes.

Keep reading

Members-only research

Members are reading this

The thesis, the numbers behind it, and what would break it. Full access is $39 a month.

Read the full research

Get a full issue free

Enter your email and we'll send you a complete Yield Theory issue, then the opening of each new one. Unsubscribe anytime.