Legal & General, Aviva or M&G: Which Insurer Dividend Beats a 5% Gilt?

· Members

Only two of the four still pay you properly for the risk, for opposite reasons. Legal & General's 7.1% dividend yield beats a 5.35% gilt by the widest margin, but grows just 2% a year. Aviva yields less than the gilt, yet its dividend grows about 7% a year.

The four insurers against a 5.35% gilt
L&GAvivaM&GStandard Life
Share price, 16 Nov305.4p762.0p332.2p945.0p
Dividend yield, 2025 payout7.1%5.2%6.2%5.9%
Extra over the 10-year gilt+⁠1.8 pts−⁠0.2 pts+⁠0.8 pts+⁠0.5 pts
Latest dividend growth+⁠2.0%+⁠6.9%+⁠1.5%+⁠2.6%
Dividend cover, own measure1.24x1.93x1.56x2.65x
Solvency ratio, latest213%179%247%169%
Yield plus guided growth (our estimate)9.3%12.5%8.3%8.5%
Source: Company results and trading updates; Yahoo Finance; CNBC. Growth is each 2026 interim dividend against the 2025 interim. Cover is 2025 capital generation over the 2025 dividend, on each company's own measure.

L&G's 1.8 point premium over the 10-year gilt is the widest of the big four London-listed life insurers, but its dividend is also the most thinly covered. Aviva's is covered almost twice over. M&G and Standard Life sit in between, offering 0.5 to 0.8 points over a risk-free gilt with less growth than Aviva and less income than L&G.

For all four, the extra yield over gilts is the thinnest in at least a decade. At the end of each year from 2016 to 2025, L&G yielded on average 4.8 points more than the 10-year gilt. Today the gap is 1.8 points.

The extra yield insurers pay over a 10-year gilt has nearly gone
−20246810 pts201620182020202120222024Nov 2026Gilts near 0.25%Aviva below the gilt1.8 ptsLegal & General−0.2 ptsAviva0.5 ptsStandard Life0.8 ptsM&G20164.5 pts3.5 pts5.1 pts20174.4 pts4.2 pts5.2 pts20185.8 pts6.7 pts6.8 pts20194.9 pts2.8 pts5.3 pts20206.4 pts6.2 pts6.5 pts9.0 pts20215.2 pts4.4 pts6.5 pts8.2 pts20224.0 pts3.2 pts4.6 pts6.6 pts20234.5 pts4.1 pts6.2 pts5.2 pts20244.8 pts3.1 pts6.1 pts5.6 pts20253.9 pts1.3 pts3.1 pts2.7 ptsNov 20261.8 pts−0.2 pts0.5 pts0.8 pts
Dividend yield on each financial year's declared dividend minus the 10-year gilt yield, in percentage points. Year ends use the Bank of England's 10-year par yield. November 2026 uses 16 November share prices, 2025 dividends and the 5.35% benchmark 10-year gilt. Standard Life traded as Phoenix until March 2026; M&G starts in 2020, its first full year after listing.Source: Yield Theory analysis of company dividend records, Yahoo Finance prices, Bank of England and CNBC gilt yields

That changes the question for an income investor. When a gilt paid 1%, almost any solid dividend beat it. At 5.35% you are now paid very little extra for the two risks a gilt doesn't carry: that the dividend is cut, as Aviva's was in 2020, and that the share price falls. A dividend still has one thing a gilt lacks: it can grow. So the test is yield plus growth, backed by a dividend the business can comfortably afford.

Our ranking: Aviva for total return, L&G for income today, M&G as the safe middle, and Standard Life only after it sets new targets on 30 November. The rest of this issue shows the working: how much capital each company generates against its dividend, what higher gilt yields do to their balance sheets, how cheap each looks against its own history, and bull, base and bear cases for each share.

Why has the yield premium over gilts disappeared?

It was squeezed from both ends. The shares rallied, which lowers their dividend yield, and gilt yields rose. From the last close of 2025 to 16 November, Standard Life rose 28.2%, L&G 16.6%, M&G 16.0% and Aviva 11.3%, all ahead of the FTSE 100's 9.6%. Over the same period the Bank of England's 10-year par yield went from 4.47% to 5.25% on 12 November, and the benchmark 10-year gilt closed near 5.35% on 16 November.

All four insurers beat the FTSE 100 in 2026, which shrank their yields
Standard Life+28.2%
Legal & General+16.6%
M&G+16.0%
Aviva+11.3%
FTSE 100+9.6%

Share price change from 31 December 2025 to 16 November 2026, dividends excluded.

Source: Yield Theory analysis of Yahoo Finance closing prices

Take L&G. Its 2025 dividend of 21.79p was worth 8.3% of its 261.9p share price at the end of last year. The price has since risen to 305.4p, so the same dividend is now worth 7.1%. Meanwhile the gilt it competes with went from about 4.5% to about 5.35%. A 3.9 point premium became 1.8 points without L&G's dividend changing at all.

The gilt side of that squeeze is the story of the past fortnight: markets now expect the Bank of England to raise rates again, and a global bond selloff pushed yields higher everywhere. Our free page on why gilt yields are rising covers the causes.

How do you compare a dividend with a gilt?

Companies in this article

Keep reading

Members-only research

Members are reading this

The thesis, the numbers behind it, and what would break it. Full access is $39 a month.

Read the full research

Get a full issue free

Enter your email and we'll send you a complete Yield Theory issue, then the opening of each new one. Unsubscribe anytime.