Legal & General, Aviva or M&G: Which Insurer Dividend Beats a 5% Gilt?
· Members
Only two of the four still pay you properly for the risk, for opposite reasons. Legal & General's 7.1% dividend yield beats a 5.35% gilt by the widest margin, but grows just 2% a year. Aviva yields less than the gilt, yet its dividend grows about 7% a year.
The four insurers against a 5.35% gilt
L&G
Aviva
M&G
Standard Life
Share price, 16 Nov
305.4p
762.0p
332.2p
945.0p
Dividend yield, 2025 payout
7.1%
5.2%
6.2%
5.9%
Extra over the 10-year gilt
+1.8 pts
−0.2 pts
+0.8 pts
+0.5 pts
Latest dividend growth
+2.0%
+6.9%
+1.5%
+2.6%
Dividend cover, own measure
1.24x
1.93x
1.56x
2.65x
Solvency ratio, latest
213%
179%
247%
169%
Yield plus guided growth (our estimate)
9.3%
12.5%
8.3%
8.5%
Source: Company results and trading updates; Yahoo Finance; CNBC. Growth is each 2026 interim dividend against the 2025 interim. Cover is 2025 capital generation over the 2025 dividend, on each company's own measure.
L&G's 1.8 point premium over the 10-year gilt is the widest of the big four London-listed life insurers, but its dividend is also the most thinly covered. Aviva's is covered almost twice over. M&G and Standard Life sit in between, offering 0.5 to 0.8 points over a risk-free gilt with less growth than Aviva and less income than L&G.
For all four, the extra yield over gilts is the thinnest in at least a decade. At the end of each year from 2016 to 2025, L&G yielded on average 4.8 points more than the 10-year gilt. Today the gap is 1.8 points.
The extra yield insurers pay over a 10-year gilt has nearly gone
Dividend yield on each financial year's declared dividend minus the 10-year gilt yield, in percentage points. Year ends use the Bank of England's 10-year par yield. November 2026 uses 16 November share prices, 2025 dividends and the 5.35% benchmark 10-year gilt. Standard Life traded as Phoenix until March 2026; M&G starts in 2020, its first full year after listing.Source: Yield Theory analysis of company dividend records, Yahoo Finance prices, Bank of England and CNBC gilt yields
That changes the question for an income investor. When a gilt paid 1%, almost any solid dividend beat it. At 5.35% you are now paid very little extra for the two risks a gilt doesn't carry: that the dividend is cut, as Aviva's was in 2020, and that the share price falls. A dividend still has one thing a gilt lacks: it can grow. So the test is yield plus growth, backed by a dividend the business can comfortably afford.
Our ranking: Aviva for total return, L&G for income today, M&G as the safe middle, and Standard Life only after it sets new targets on 30 November. The rest of this issue shows the working: how much capital each company generates against its dividend, what higher gilt yields do to their balance sheets, how cheap each looks against its own history, and bull, base and bear cases for each share.
Why has the yield premium over gilts disappeared?
It was squeezed from both ends. The shares rallied, which lowers their dividend yield, and gilt yields rose. From the last close of 2025 to 16 November, Standard Life rose 28.2%, L&G 16.6%, M&G 16.0% and Aviva 11.3%, all ahead of the FTSE 100's 9.6%. Over the same period the Bank of England's 10-year par yield went from 4.47% to 5.25% on 12 November, and the benchmark 10-year gilt closed near 5.35% on 16 November.
All four insurers beat the FTSE 100 in 2026, which shrank their yields
Standard Life+28.2%
Legal & General+16.6%
M&G+16.0%
Aviva+11.3%
FTSE 100+9.6%
Share price change from 31 December 2025 to 16 November 2026, dividends excluded.
Source: Yield Theory analysis of Yahoo Finance closing prices
Take L&G. Its 2025 dividend of 21.79p was worth 8.3% of its 261.9p share price at the end of last year. The price has since risen to 305.4p, so the same dividend is now worth 7.1%. Meanwhile the gilt it competes with went from about 4.5% to about 5.35%. A 3.9 point premium became 1.8 points without L&G's dividend changing at all.
The gilt side of that squeeze is the story of the past fortnight: markets now expect the Bank of England to raise rates again, and a global bond selloff pushed yields higher everywhere. Our free page on why gilt yields are rising covers the causes.
How do you compare a dividend with a gilt?
A gilt held to repayment pays a fixed amount, backed by the government, and any gain on it is free of Capital Gains Tax. A dividend can grow, but it can also be cut, and the share can fall. So a fair comparison needs three numbers, not one:
Yield plus growth. If a share's dividend yield stays the same, its price rises in line with the dividend, so your yearly return is roughly the yield plus the dividend's growth rate. This is a simple valuation rule, not a forecast; it ignores changes in how the market values the share.
Cover. Insurers pay dividends out of the surplus capital their business throws off each year, which they call capital generation (each uses a slightly different measure). Cover is that surplus divided by the cost of the dividend. Below about 1x, the dividend relies on something else, such as selling businesses.
Solvency ratio. The Solvency II ratio is the capital an insurer holds divided by what regulators require. Each company sets a target range; above it means spare capital, below it means pressure on payouts.
Each company measures capital generation its own way, so cover is best compared within a company over time; across companies, treat a gap of a few tenths as noise and a gap of 1x as real.
On the first test, all four beat a gilt on paper: 8.3% to 12.5% against 5.35%. The other two tests decide how much of that extra return you can trust. Our ranking weighs all three, then checks how each share fares if gilt yields keep rising.
Which insurer has the best dividend record?
L&G has the strongest record. Over the past decade it raised its dividend every year except 2020, when it held it flat, and it grew at 4.75% a year. Standard Life and M&G have never cut either, but have grown more slowly. Aviva is the only one of the four to have cut.
Dividend per share
Start of our record
2025
Growth a year
Cut in the decade?
Legal & General
14.35p (2016)
21.79p
4.75%
No, held flat in 2020
Aviva
23.30p (2016)
39.30p
Not comparable
Yes, in 2020
Standard Life
41.9p (2016)
55.4p
3.15%
No
M&G
18.23p (2020)
20.5p
2.37%
No, listed in 2019
Standard Life's 2016 figure is the company's own series, adjusted for its 2016 and 2018 rights issues. Aviva's per-share figures before 2022 are on a different share count after it returned £3.75bn and consolidated its shares, so a growth rate across that change would mislead. A record is not a guarantee: a policy is only as good as the capital behind it, which is what the next four sections test.
Is Legal & General's 7% dividend safe?
For the next two years, very likely. L&G has promised 2% a year dividend growth to 2027, holds a solvency ratio of 213%, well above its 160% to 190% operating range, and has not cut its dividend in at least a decade. After 2027 it depends on whether its pension buyout business recovers, because the dividend now uses almost all the capital L&G's business generates.
Legal & General in four numbers
7.1%Dividend yieldOn 21.79p for 2025, at 305.4p
1.02xCover after new business1.24x before new business strain
213%Solvency ratio30 September; range 160% to 190%
£3.7bnQ3 pension buyoutsAgainst £4.6bn expected
Source: Legal & General results and Q3 2026 trading update; Yield Theory calculation
The record is good. L&G's dividend rose from 14.35p for 2016 to 21.79p for 2025, 4.75% a year, and was held flat at 17.57p in 2020 when many companies cut. In June 2024 it changed its policy: after a 5% rise for 2024 it would "aim to increase it by 2% from then on," returning more through buybacks instead. It has committed to more than £5bn of total returns over 2025 to 2027, about 40% of its market value at the start of 2025, and by 13 November had spent £846m of a £1.2bn buyback for 2026.
The cover is where it gets tighter. In 2025 L&G's operational surplus generation, its measure of the capital its existing book throws off, was £1,530m against a dividend costing £1,235m: 1.24x. But writing new business, mostly pension buyouts, consumes capital up front, called new business strain. After that strain, L&G's net surplus generation was £1,264m, which covers the dividend just 1.02 times.
After new business, L&G's 2025 capital covered its dividend with £29m to spare
Operational surplus generation£1,530m
New business strain−£266m= £1,264m
2025 dividends−£1,235m= £29m
Left for buybacks and growth£29m
New business strain is the gap between L&G's reported operational surplus generation (£1,530m) and net surplus generation (£1,264m). The 2025 dividend cost is the interim (£349m) plus the final (£886m).Source: Legal & General 2025 results; Yield Theory calculation
So where does the £1.2bn buyback come from? Mainly from selling things. L&G completed the sale of its US protection business to Meiji Yasuda on 2 February 2026 for $2.6bn, booking a £1,398m gain, and it expects more than £400m a year from what it calls asset optimisation. That is a legitimate use of disposal proceeds, but it is not recurring. The ordinary dividend is affordable from the existing book; growth beyond 2% needs the new business engines to fire.
They are misfiring. L&G's third-quarter update on 16 November showed £5.8bn of pension risk transfer (PRT, the business of taking over company pension schemes) in the first nine months, against £5.9bn a year earlier. The third quarter alone was £3.7bn against £4.6bn expected by the nine analysts in L&G's own consensus. Asset management lost £28bn of client money in the nine months, and L&G is cutting around 1,000 jobs by mid-2027. The shares fell 2.96% on the day while the FTSE 100 fell 0.19%.
Two things soften that. L&G still expects 2026 core operating earnings per share to grow faster than the top of its 6% to 9% target range, and higher gilt yields lifted its solvency ratio from 201% in June to 213% in September. On the analysts' consensus of 23.45p for 2026, the shares trade at 13.0 times earnings.
Our view: L&G is the pick if you need income now and can live with 2% growth. People searching whether L&G's dividend has been suspended can relax; it hasn't, and with cover just above 1x and a 213% solvency ratio, nothing in its numbers points that way while the 2027 commitment stands. But the 7.1% yield is the market's price for slow growth and a buyout business that is stalling, not a mistake waiting to be corrected.
Why own Aviva when it yields less than a gilt?
Because its dividend is growing three times as fast as the others, and the business behind it faster still. Aviva paid 39.3p for 2025, up 10%, and its 2026 interim of 14.0p is up 6.9%. Add that growth to a 5.2% yield and Aviva offers about 12.5% a year if its yield holds, the most of the four.
Aviva's dividend has grown every year since its 2022 reset
202231.0p
202333.4p
202435.7p
202539.3p
Total dividend per share for each financial year. Figures before 2022 are on a different share count after Aviva's 2022 share consolidation and are not comparable.
Source: Aviva annual results
Aviva in four numbers
5.2%Dividend yieldOn 39.3p for 2025, at 762.0p
1.93xDividend coverOperating own funds generation, 2025
179%Solvency ratio30 September; high-180s expected by year end
11%Earnings growth targetOperating EPS, a year to 2028
Source: Aviva results and Q3 2026 trading update; Yield Theory calculation
The policy explains the speed. Aviva aims "to grow the cash cost of the dividend by a mid-single digit percentage each year," and says buybacks "further uplift the dividend per share" by shrinking the share count. It bought back £350m of shares this year. Earnings are doing the work: operating earnings per share rose 17% to 56.0p in 2025 and 10% to 31.8p in the first half of 2026, return on equity reached 20.3%, and on 13 November Aviva repeated that it expects 2026 growth "broadly in line with our 11% target rate."
Cover is comfortable. Aviva's 2025 operating own funds generation, its version of capital generation, was £2,317m against a £1,200m dividend: 1.93x. Its solvency ratio was 179% at the end of September, at the top of its 160% to 180% working range, and Aviva expects "the high-180s" by the end of the year, helped by more than 7 points of remaining savings from its Direct Line takeover.
There are soft spots. Aviva's bulk annuity sales halved in the first nine months to £1,946m from £3,890m, "as we observed lower quote activity and competition remained high," and total retirement sales fell 34%. The shares already rose 3.4% on its third-quarter update, so good news is partly in the price. At 762p, Aviva trades at 13.6 times its 2025 operating earnings and 12.0 times its first-half earnings of 31.8p doubled.
Our view: Aviva is the best total-return case of the four and the worst for someone who needs income today, when a gilt pays more. Its low yield also makes it the most sensitive to further rises in gilt yields, which we quantify below.
Is M&G's dividend worth it?
It is the safest of the four on capital, but you are paid just 0.8 points over a gilt for a dividend growing about 2% a year. M&G's solvency ratio was 247% in June, far above its 160% to 190% range, and it has not cut since listing in 2019: 18.23p for 2020, 20.5p for 2025.
M&G in four numbers
6.2%Dividend yieldOn 20.5p for 2025, at 332.2p
1.56xDividend coverOperating capital generation, 2025
247%Solvency ratio30 June; range 160% to 190%
£4.2bnNet new moneyOpen business, first nine months of 2026
Source: M&G results and Q3 2026 trading update; Yield Theory calculation
M&G describes its policy as "progressive and sustainable" and applied 2% rises for 2024 and 2025. Its chief financial officer was candid on the half-year call: "We kept it at 2% last year despite flat earnings." That is the trade-off. In 2025 operating capital generation after new business strain fell to £765m from £933m, which covers the £489m dividend 1.56 times; before new business strain it was £928m, or 1.9x.
The business is improving. Adjusted operating profit before tax rose 15% to £435m in the first half, and M&G expects "low double-digit" growth for 2026. Its open business took in £4.2bn of net new money in the first nine months, and annuity sales of £1.8bn are on course to pass £2.5bn this year, from £1.5bn in all of 2025. Daiichi Life, the Japanese insurer, owns 15.7% and has a seat on the board.
M&G doesn't publish operating earnings per share, so a normal P/E isn't available. Its market value is 9.55 times its 2025 adjusted operating profit before tax; if that profit were taxed at the 25% UK rate, the P/E would be about 12.7, our illustration rather than a reported figure. Note too that M&G's third-quarter update gave no capital figures, so the 247% dates from June.
Our view: M&G is fairly priced for income, not cheap. The upside case is capital, not dividends: with a ratio that high and no buyback since 2022, a return of surplus capital would lift the shares. Until then, a 6.2% yield growing 2% beats a gilt by too little to be compelling.
Should you wait on Standard Life?
Probably until 30 November, when it sets targets for the enlarged group. Standard Life, which renamed itself from Phoenix in March 2026, has the best cash cover of the four and the most moving parts.
Standard Life in four numbers
5.9%Dividend yieldOn 55.4p for 2025, at 945.0p
2.65xCash coverOperating cash generation, 2025
169%Capital coverage ratio30 June; range 140% to 180%
−£218mIFRS shareholders' equity30 June 2026
Source: Standard Life 2026 half-year results; Yield Theory calculation
Its dividend has risen every year, from 46.0p for 2018 to 55.4p for 2025, and its policy is "progressive and sustainable," with each interim set equal to the previous final. In 2025 operating cash generation of £1,474m covered the £557m dividend 2.65 times. On its Solvency II measure the margin is thinner: recurring capital generation of about £0.9bn before dividends, or 1.6x cover.
The balance sheet is where the questions are. Standard Life's IFRS shareholders' equity was negative £218m in June, its regulatory Solvency II ratio 146% and its shareholder capital coverage ratio 169%, within a 140% to 180% range. Cash at its holding companies fell from £846m at the end of 2025 to £556m in June as it repaid £503m of debt; it says 2026 is the "final year of using excess cash to de-lever."
Then there is the deal. Standard Life agreed in April to buy Aegon UK for £2.0bn: £750m in cash and 181.1 million new shares at 690p, leaving Aegon with 15.3%. It expects £160m a year of extra operating cash generation and completion around the end of 2026. It has also set up a partnership with a CVC-led consortium, with up to £2bn of combined capital, to fund pension buyouts, committing £500m of its own over five years. Aberdeen, a long-standing holder, sold 52 million shares on 8 October.
On valuation it is the most split of the four. Its market value is just 6.5 times its operating cash generation, the cheapest on cash, but 17.4 times its 2025 operating earnings per share, the most expensive on earnings. And at 5.9% its yield is the lowest of any year end in our ten-year record.
Our view: after a 28% rise this year, the good news is priced. The 30 November targets will show how much of the Aegon cash uplift goes to dividends. We'd wait for them.
Is the pension buyout slowdown a threat to dividends?
Not directly, but it is a threat to dividend growth. Pension buyouts are how three of the four grow, and the market is shrinking. Consultants LCP and Aon both put 2025 volumes at £38.2bn, down from £47.8bn in 2024, and the first half of 2026 brought only £10.2bn. Forecasts for 2026 have been cut from as much as £55bn (LCP in January) to between £30bn and £40bn (WTW, LCP and Aon this autumn).
UK pension buyouts fell in 2025 and forecasts for 2026 keep falling
2024£47.8bn
2025£38.2bn
2026 forecast, January£40bn to £55bn
2026 forecast, autumn£30bn to £40bn
First half of 2026£10.2bn
Bulk annuity volumes. The January forecast is LCP's; the autumn range spans WTW, LCP and Aon.
Source: LCP, Aon and WTW market reports
The consultants give three reasons: almost no very large deals (one above £1bn in the first half), fierce price competition that LCP says has improved terms for schemes by about 3% this year, and schemes pausing to consider running on rather than selling. The Pension Schemes Act 2026, which became law on 29 April, will let well-funded schemes release surplus to employers, and the government's consultation put aggregate surpluses at around £160bn. Draft regulations are still being finalised. Meanwhile private capital has moved in: Brookfield took Just Group private in April and Athora bought Pension Insurance Corporation in March.
Here is the twist for dividends. Writing less new business means less new business strain, so a slow year can actually leave more capital for payouts in the short run. The damage shows up later, as slower growth in the book that pays future dividends. L&G is most exposed because buyouts are its main growth engine; Aviva's halving shows in its retirement sales; M&G is growing from a small base; Standard Life is sharing the capital cost through its partnership.
Do higher gilt yields help or hurt insurers?
Both: they strengthen the balance sheets and weaken the share prices. Life insurers hold long-dated liabilities, and higher yields shrink the present value of those liabilities faster than the capital requirement, so solvency ratios rise. Between June and September the Bank of England's 10-year par yield rose 0.63 points, and L&G's ratio went from 201% to 213% while Aviva credited "positive market movements from interest rate rises."
Each insurer's solvency ratio gains when yields rise
Change in solvency ratio
L&G
Aviva
Standard Life
M&G
Interest rates up 1 point
+9 pts
+8 pts
+4 pts
Not published
Interest rates down 1 point
−12 pts
−9 pts
−5 pts
−3 pts for 0.5 point
Credit downgrades
−8 pts
−3 pts
−7 pts
−4 pts
Ratio at the test date
201%
176%
169%
247%
Source: Company half-year 2026 disclosures, as at 30 June 2026. Credit downgrades are each company's published stress: a 20% full letter downgrade for L&G, Standard Life and M&G; Aviva's covers its annuity portfolio.
The share prices are the other side. Income investors compare dividend yields with gilt yields, so when gilts pay more, insurer shares need higher yields, which means lower prices for the same dividend. That is the squeeze in our opening chart. The real danger is a recession that pushes up corporate defaults, because these insurers back annuities with corporate bonds; the downgrade row above shows L&G and Standard Life are the most exposed to that.
Does tax change the answer?
Inside an ISA or a pension, no: dividends and gilt income are both tax-free. Outside one, it can flip the result for a higher-rate taxpayer. Dividends above the £500 dividend allowance are taxed at 10.75% for basic-rate and 35.75% for higher-rate taxpayers from April 2026. Gains on gilts are free of Capital Gains Tax, so a gilt with a tiny coupon pays almost all of its return tax-free. The 0⅛% Treasury Gilt 2028, sold by the Debt Management Office on 11 November at a yield of 4.185%, is the clearest example.
Yield after tax, allowances used up
Before tax
Basic rate
Higher rate
Legal & General
7.13%
6.37%
4.58%
M&G
6.17%
5.51%
3.96%
Standard Life
5.86%
5.23%
3.77%
Aviva
5.16%
4.60%
3.31%
0⅛% Treasury Gilt 2028
4.19%
4.16%
4.14%
For a higher-rate taxpayer outside an ISA, only L&G still pays more income than a low-coupon gilt, by less than half a point, and with none of the gilt's certainty. That is a strong argument for holding these shares inside an ISA, and for anyone who can't to look hard at gilts first. The gilt figure ignores dealing costs and is a short-dated bond, so it answers the income question, not the growth one.
How cheap are they against their own history?
On yield alone, L&G and Aviva are in the middle of their ten-year ranges, while M&G and Standard Life are at the bottom. On premium over gilts, all four are at their lowest.
Valuation against each insurer's own record
L&G
Aviva
M&G
Standard Life
Dividend yield now
7.1%
5.2%
6.2%
5.9%
Year-end yields, 2016 to 2025
5.6% to 9.3%
3.7% to 8.0%
7.2% to 10.4%
6.3% to 10.6%
Average premium over gilts
4.8 pts
3.9 pts
6.2 pts
5.5 pts
Premium now
1.8 pts
−0.2 pts
0.8 pts
0.5 pts
Price to 2025 operating earnings
14.6x
13.6x
12.7x (illustrative)
17.4x
Capital generation as % of market value
9.3%
10.1%
9.6%
15.5%
Source: Yield Theory analysis of company results, Yahoo Finance prices and Bank of England gilt yields. M&G's record covers 2020 to 2025. Capital generation is each company's own 2025 measure.
Each company's 2025 capital generation, divided by its market value, gives a rough "earnings yield" on surplus capital. All four generate 9% to 16% of their market value a year, comfortably above a 5.35% gilt; they choose to pay out only part of it. Standard Life's 15.5% looks the most generous, but part of its cash has been going to repay debt, and the Aegon deal will add shares.
Bull, base and bear: what could each share return?
We built three cases for the next twelve months around the two things that drive these shares: the 10-year gilt yield and the premium investors demand over it. In each case the share price is next year's dividend divided by the yield investors require, which is the gilt yield plus the premium. Total return adds a year of dividends.
Bull: the 10-year gilt falls back to 4.5%, roughly where it started 2026, on a ceasefire and inflation peaking. Each share's premium stays where it is.
Base: the gilt stays at 5.35% and premiums hold, so prices rise in line with dividends.
Bear: the gilt rises to 6%, the level the Office for Budget Responsibility's forecast assumes for gilt rates by 2031-32, and premiums widen by 1 point back toward their history.
Twelve-month price and total return in each case
Bull
Base
Bear
Legal & General (305.4p)
354p, +23%
312p, +9%
253p, −10%
Aviva (762.0p)
977p, +34%
815p, +12%
618p, −13%
M&G (332.2p)
393p, +25%
339p, +8%
267p, −13%
Standard Life (945.0p)
1,133p, +26%
969p, +9%
756p, −14%
Source: Yield Theory estimates. Next year's dividend grows at 2% (L&G, M&G), 2.5% (Standard Life) and 7% (Aviva). Starting prices are 16 November closes; premiums are measured against a 5.35% gilt.
L&G's high yield is a cushion: it loses least in the bear case, about 10%, because a big dividend makes up more of the return. Aviva has the most to gain if yields fall and the most to lose if they rise, because a low yield makes its price more sensitive to any change in the yield investors require.
A half-point rise in gilt yields hits Aviva hardest
Aviva−9.1%
Standard Life−8.3%
M&G−7.9%
Legal & General−6.9%
Price change if the 10-year gilt yield rises 0.5 points and each share's premium over it holds. Our estimate.
Source: Yield Theory estimates
These cases simplify. They treat each premium as fixed when in reality it moves with company news, they assume dividends grow as guided, and they ignore buybacks. Use them for direction and relative size, not precise targets.
Which is the best UK insurance share for income?
It depends on what you need the money to do.
You need the most income now, inside an ISA: Legal & General. The highest yield, a promise of 2% growth to 2027 and the smallest loss in our bear case. Accept that growth is slow and the buyout business is stalling.
You are reinvesting for five years or more: Aviva. The lowest yield today, but the fastest-growing dividend and the strongest earnings momentum. It needs gilt yields to stop rising to shine.
You want the strongest balance sheet: M&G. A 247% solvency ratio, steady 2% rises and the option of a capital return, for a premium over gilts of under 1 point.
You already own Standard Life: hold until the 30 November targets. Buying more before then is a bet on what they say.
You are a higher-rate taxpayer outside an ISA: compare with a low-coupon gilt first. After tax, it pays about as much as L&G with no risk to your capital if held to repayment.
Key risks
Gilt yields keep rising. Markets expect Bank Rate near 4.75% by spring. Each half point on the 10-year gilt costs these shares 7% to 9% if premiums hold, and more if investors also demand a bigger premium.
A credit shock. A recession that pushes up corporate defaults would hit the bonds that back annuities. A 20% downgrade costs L&G 8 solvency points and Standard Life 7, and would make boards more cautious on payouts.
The buyout market keeps shrinking. If 2026 lands near £30bn and surplus release keeps schemes running on, L&G's main growth engine slows for years, not quarters.
Deal and execution risk at Standard Life. Aegon UK has a long stop date of 15 April 2027, is funded partly with £650m of new debt raised this year, and adds 181.1 million shares to the dividend bill.
Asset management outflows. L&G lost £28bn of client money in nine months; fee income funds part of its dividend.
Policy changes. All four set dividends at the board's discretion. Aviva's 2020 reset shows a policy can change quickly when conditions do.
What would change our view
Legal & General: a strong fourth quarter for buyouts and a 2026 net surplus generation clearly above the dividend would make the 7.1% yield look too high. Another miss, or guidance for 2028 below 2% growth, would make it a pure income trap.
Aviva: missing its 11% earnings growth target or a solvency ratio stuck below 180% would undermine the growth case, which is all it has over a gilt.
M&G: a buyback or special payout from its 247% ratio would turn us positive. A fall in operating capital generation below £700m would put the 2% rises at risk.
Standard Life: 30 November targets showing faster dividend growth from the Aegon cash would make it the best value on cash. Targets that send the uplift mainly to debt would confirm that the 28% rally has run ahead.
When are the next dividends paid?
All four pay twice a year: an interim in the autumn and a final in the spring, which M&G calls a second interim. Each announces its final with full-year results, which all four published in March this year. Here is what they paid this year, as a guide to timing.
2026 payments
Final for 2025
Ex-dividend
Interim for 2026
Ex-dividend
Legal & General
15.67p
23 Apr
6.24p
20 Aug
Aviva
26.2p
26 Mar
14.0p
3 Sep
M&G
13.8p
19 Mar
6.8p
10 Sep
Standard Life
28.05p
9 Apr
28.05p
24 Sep
You must own the shares before the ex-dividend date to receive the payment. Standard Life sets its interim equal to the previous final and M&G sets its interim at a third of the previous year's total, so their next interims are close to predictable: about 28.7p and 7.0p if 2026 totals grow as guided.
What to watch next
Dates that could move insurer shares
18 NovUK October inflationSets the odds of a December rate rise
30 NovStandard Life targetsCapital Markets Update after Aegon UK
17 DecBank of England decision
Around year endAegon UK deal completesLong stop date 15 April 2027
February 2027M&G board discusses 2026 dividend
8 Mar 2027L&G full-year results2026 dividend and buyout volumes
Where our numbers could be off
Dividend cover uses each company's own capital measure, and they are not like for like: L&G's operational surplus generation excludes new business strain, M&G's operating capital generation includes it, and Standard Life's operating cash generation is a cash measure rather than a capital one. Our premiums use the benchmark 10-year gilt at 5.35%; the Bank of England's par yield, 5.25% on 12 November, would make each premium about 0.1 point bigger. Year-end yields use dividends that were only confirmed after each year end, so they are not exactly what a buyer saw at the time. Aviva's history before 2022 and Phoenix's before 2018 are adjusted for share consolidations and rights issues, and M&G's record leaves out its part-year 2019, which included a special dividend. Standard Life and M&G have published no capital figures since June. Our scenarios assume dividends grow as guided, and Aviva's 7% is our estimate from its recent record, not a promise.
Our read
A 5.35% gilt has taken away most of the reward for owning UK life insurers for income. The premium over gilts is the thinnest in at least a decade for all four, so the bar is now growth and cover, not yield.
Aviva clears it best: a dividend growing about 7% a year, covered almost twice, from a business targeting 11% earnings growth. We would own it for total return and accept two costs: a gilt pays more income today, and Aviva falls furthest if gilt yields keep rising. L&G is the income choice, with the biggest yield and the best cushion in our bear case, but its dividend now absorbs nearly all the capital its business generates and its buyout engine is stalling, so don't expect much growth. M&G is solid but pays too little extra for its slow growth unless it returns capital. Standard Life is worth revisiting after 30 November.
If gilt yields fall back toward 4.5%, all four rally and Aviva most. If they climb toward 6%, L&G holds up best. That makes your view on rates part of the choice.
How we built this
Dividends and capital: each company's annual and half-year results, third-quarter updates and dividend pages, cross-checked against Yahoo Finance dividend records. L&G and Aviva published third-quarter updates on 16 and 13 November; M&G on 5 November; Standard Life has not published one.
Prices: Yahoo Finance closing prices to 16 November 2026, matched against CNBC. Share price changes exclude dividends.
Gilt yields: the Bank of England's 10-year par yield for year ends and for 12 November; the CNBC benchmark 10-year gilt (5.35%) for 16 November.
Pension buyout market: LCP, Aon and WTW market reports, named where cited. Pension Schemes Act status from GOV.UK.
Tax: dividend and savings tax rates from GOV.UK for 2026-27; the gilt example uses the Debt Management Office's 11 November tender result.
Calculations: yields are the declared dividend for each financial year over the year-end price; cover is 2025 capital generation over the 2025 dividend cost; scenarios divide next year's dividend by the gilt yield plus each share's premium. All inputs are shown in the text.
Go deeper
Why are gilt yields rising?: what pushed the two-year gilt above 5% and whether the Bank of England raises rates in December.
Imperial Brands yields 5.7% and cash covered its dividend 2.1 times. BAT yields 5.4% and its dividend took all its free cash flow. Our pick and the maths.
RELX trades 37% below its peak and at about 19.5 times earnings, down from 34, even though its profit per share keeps rising. We test the AI fears against what RELX, LSEG, Experian, Wolters Kluwer, Sage, Pearson, Rightmove and Auto Trader actually reported.
The thesis, the numbers behind it, and what would break it. Full access is $39 a month.