Imperial Brands or BAT? The 5.7% Dividend After Up to 4,600 Job Cuts
· Members
Imperial Brands has the safer dividend, and at Tuesday's prices it is the tobacco share we would own for income. It yields 5.7%, covered 2.1 times by free cash flow. British American Tobacco (BAT) yields 5.4%, and its dividend took all its free cash flow.
Imperial is cheaper and its dividend is better covered; BAT is further ahead in smoke-free products
At the 17 Nov close
Imperial Brands
BAT
Share price
2,918p
4,524p
Dividend yield
5.7%
5.4%
Price to adjusted earnings
8.6
12.8
Times the dividend was covered by free cash flow
2.1 (year to Sep 2026)
1.0 (year to Jun 2026)
Net debt divided by a year's profit before interest, tax and depreciation (EBITDA)
2.0
2.5 (Dec 2025)
Buyback as a share of market value
6.8%
1.3%
Latest dividend increase
4.0%
2.0%
Smoke-free share of revenue
4.9%
19.8%
Source: Imperial Brands results for the year to 30 Sep 2026; BAT results for 2025 and the half year to 30 Jun 2026; Hargreaves Lansdown closing prices; Yield Theory calculations
Free cash flow is the cash left after running the business. Imperial's covered its dividend 2.1 times last year, and its shares cost 8.6 times adjusted earnings. BAT's shares cost 12.8 times earnings, and its dividend took all the free cash flow it made over the past twelve months.
We do not expect Imperial to return more than BAT. Our base case is about 38% over three years for both. The difference is what each return rests on: Imperial's on cash it has already made, BAT's on a recovery in cash flow that has not shown up yet. The catch with Imperial is its £1.5bn-a-year share buyback. If cash comes in at the bottom of its guidance, a fifth of next year's payout will be borrowed, which puts the buyback, and about two points of earnings growth, at risk before the dividend.
The two companies report on different calendars: Imperial's figures are for the year to September 2026, BAT's dividend and earnings are for calendar 2025, and its cash flow is for the twelve months to June 2026. Imperial's 8.6 is on earnings before almost £1bn of restructuring, legal and accounting charges. On earnings after them it is 12.1, which we come back to under valuation.
Imperial reported full-year results on Tuesday 17 November. It raised its dividend 4%, promised another £1.5bn of share buybacks, and confirmed job cuts that the Guardian and others added up to 4,600: 2,100 already decided and up to 2,500 more by 2030. The shares fell 1.98% on a day the FTSE 100 fell 1.76%. BAT said nothing and fell 3.95%.
Is the Imperial Brands dividend safe?
Yes. Profit or cash covers it between 1.5 and 2.1 times, depending on the measure.
"Cover" is how many times a company could pay its dividend out of profit or cash. As a rule of thumb, 1.5 times or more leaves room for a bad year. Below 1.0 the company is paying out more than it makes.
Adjusted earnings leave out costs the company treats as one-offs, which came to almost £1bn this year. Reported earnings include everything. We come back to that gap below.
Cover measure
Calculation
Cover
Adjusted earnings per share
341.0p divided by 166.72p
2.0 times
Reported earnings per share
242.9p divided by 166.72p
1.5 times
Free cash flow, 2026
£2,636m divided by £1,269m
2.1 times
Free cash flow, 2027 guidance floor
£2,200m divided by about £1,250m
1.8 times
Even if free cash flow lands at the bottom of Imperial's guidance, the dividend takes 57% of it. The £1,250m for next year's dividend payments is our estimate.
The total cost of the dividend fell, from £1,314m to £1,269m, even though the payment per share rose 4.0%. That is because Imperial bought back and cancelled 52.5 million shares, 6.5% of those in issue at the start of the year. A company that raises its dividend 4% and shrinks its share count faster than that pays less in total each year. Imperial could keep this up with no profit growth at all, for as long as it can fund the buyback.
Imperial has cut before. In May 2020 it reduced the dividend by a third to pay down debt, as interactive investor reported at the time. Today's 166.72p is still 19% below the 206.6p paid for 2019.
Imperial cut its dividend by a third in 2020; BAT has raised its payout every year
100125150175200225250p2016201820202021202220242026206.6pCut by a third166.72p166.7pImperial Brands245.0pBAT2016155.2p169.4p2017170.7p195.2p2018187.8p203.0p2019206.6p210.4p2020137.7p215.6p2021139.1p217.8p2022141.2p230.9p2023146.8p235.5p2024153.4p240.2p2025160.3p245.0p2026166.7p
Dividend per share declared for each financial year. Imperial's year ends in September and BAT's in December, so BAT has not yet declared a 2026 dividend.Source: Imperial Brands and BAT annual results
Two things were different in 2019. Imperial was paying out 76% of its adjusted earnings as dividends (206.6p of 273.3p), against 49% now. And net debt was 2.9 times EBITDA, a measure of yearly profit before interest, tax and depreciation that lenders compare debt against. It is 2.0 times now. The 2020 cut was made to bring debt down, and debt is now where Imperial wants it.
Where does Imperial's 8% earnings growth come from?
More from buying back shares than from profit growth. Without the buyback, earnings per share would have grown about 2.4%, not 8.3%.
Imperial publishes the breakdown itself. Earnings per share went from 315.0p to 341.0p, a gain of 26.0p.
Buybacks added more to Imperial's earnings per share than profit growth did
Adjusted EPS, 2025315p
Higher operating profit+18p= 333p
Fewer shares+18p= 351p
Interest−3p= 348p
Tax−4p= 344p
Minority interests−1p= 343p
Currency−2p= 341p
Adjusted EPS, 2026341p
Imperial's own breakdown of the change in adjusted earnings per share. A buyback spreads the same profit over fewer shares, so each share earns more. Minority interests are the slice of profit owed to outside shareholders in subsidiaries such as the distributor Logista.Source: Imperial Brands results for the year to 30 Sep 2026
The buyback added 18.3p and higher profit added 17.8p. Interest, tax, minority shareholders and currency took back 10.1p. Take the buyback away and the gain is 7.7p, or 2.4%. That matches Imperial's total adjusted earnings in pounds, which rose 2.5%.
A buyback is a real return of cash, and at 8.6 times earnings it is a good one: every £1 spent retires shares earning about 11.6p a year. Imperial says it has cut its share count by more than 21% since October 2022, and it has committed to buybacks every year to 2030.
The growth rate now depends on the size of the buyback and on the share price, because the cheaper the shares, the more of them £1.5bn buys: 8.2% of the share count at the 52-week low of 2,408p, 6.8% at Tuesday's 2,918p and 5.5% at the 52-week high of 3,632p, on our sums. If you plan to hold for years and collect the dividend, a low share price helps you.
Can Imperial afford a £1.5bn buyback?
Not from free cash flow alone. Part of the buyback is being paid for with debt, and that part grows next year.
Imperial returned £181m more than its free cash flow in 2026
Free cash flow£2,636m
Dividends paid−£1,277m= £1,359m
Share buybacks−£1,540m= −£181m
Shortfall−£181m
Cash paid in the year to 30 September 2026. Dividends paid (£1,277m) differ slightly from dividends declared for the year (£1,269m) because some of the cash paid relates to the previous year's dividend. Free cash flow is after £118m of restructuring cash costs and a £150m legal payment in the US.Source: Imperial Brands results for the year to 30 Sep 2026; Yield Theory calculation
Imperial handed back £2,817m and generated £2,636m. Adjusted net debt, the measure it sets its target on, rose £380m to £8,786m and stayed at 2.0 times EBITDA.
Next year the gap widens. Imperial guides to free cash flow of "at least £2.2 billion". The statement gives the reasons: most of the remaining £500m of restructuring cash is paid in 2027 and 2028, the tax rate rises to between 24.5% and 25.0%, and another instalment of the US legal settlement is due.
2027, our estimate
£m
Free cash flow, at the guidance floor
2,200
Dividends paid
−1,250
Buyback
−1,500
Shortfall
−550
The dividend figure assumes another 4% rise per share, paid on a share count that keeps falling. It is slightly lower than this year's £1,277m, so the dividend bill shrinks again. If the shortfall is added to debt and EBITDA grows 3%, we estimate net debt ends the year at about £9.3bn, still close to 2.0 times EBITDA. Imperial aims to stay at the lower end of a 2.0 to 2.5 times range, so it has a little room, not a lot.
Imperial plans to pay out £2,750m, which is 12.5% of its market value. Its cash floor is £2,200m, or 10%. The £550m difference is a fifth of the payout.
Imperial guides to earnings per share growth of "at least high single-digit" next year, which we take as about 8%. How much of that rests on borrowing? After the dividend, the cash floor leaves about £950m for buybacks, not £1.5bn. That would retire about 4% of the shares a year, not 7%, and on our estimate earnings per share would grow about 6%, not 8%. So about two points of growth are borrowed.
If cash runs short, the buyback gives way before the dividend does, because the dividend takes only 57% of the guided cash. In a bad year we would expect Imperial to slow the buyback, and earnings growth would fall towards the 2% to 4% that profit alone delivers.
Imperial's plan to 2030 targets free cash flow of £2.2bn to £3.0bn a year, so £2.2bn is the bottom of its range. At £2.5bn the shortfall shrinks to about £250m, and a repeat of this year's £2,636m would cut it to about £110m.
Why is Imperial Brands cutting up to 4,600 jobs?
Because it sells fewer cigarettes every year and needs fewer factories and offices to make them. The savings pay for profit growth that volumes can no longer provide.
Imperial's own words are: "During FY26, we completed programmes that will lead to a reduction of 2,100 roles globally, and we expect a further reduction of between 2,100 and 2,500 roles by the end of 2030." It employed 25,300 people at the end of September. The first 2,100 roles are 8% of that. The full 4,600 would be 18%.
What Imperial's restructuring costs and saves
Up to 4,600Roles to go by 20302,100 decided, 2,100 to 2,500 more planned
£320mAnnual savings by 2030£90m a year delivered so far
£740mTotal cost of the programmeAbout £600m of it in cash
2.3 yearsPaybackCost divided by annual savings
Source: Imperial Brands results for the year to 30 Sep 2026; Yield Theory calculation
Savings of £320m a year, after tax at this year's 23.4% rate, are worth about £245m, or roughly 32p a share on today's share count. That is our estimate, and it equals 9.5% of this year's adjusted earnings per share.
The cost is £740m, about £600m of it cash, and about £500m of that cash goes out over the next two years. That is the main reason free cash flow dips in 2027.
Is the BAT dividend safe?
Probably, but with much less room than Imperial's. BAT has the better record and the weaker cash cover.
BAT says it has raised its dividend in pounds for 27 years in a row. The latest increase was 2.0%, to 245.04p, paid in four instalments of 61.26p. Its policy is a "progressive", meaning rising, "dividend based upon 65% of long-term sustainable earnings", and the payout was 69.6% of adjusted earnings in 2025, according to its full-year results.
On earnings, that is fine. On cash, it is tight.
BAT free cash flow before dividends
£m
Divided by the £5,238m BAT paid in dividends in 2025
2025
4,048
0.8 times
Twelve months to June 2026
5,099
1.0 times
What BAT's 2030 target needs each year
about 7,960
1.5 times
The £5,238m comes from BAT's own statement that free cash flow in 2025 was £4,048m before dividends and minus £1,190m after. The twelve-month figure is our sum from the half-year report: the 2025 total, plus the first half of 2026, less the first half of 2025.
Cash flow fell in 2025 because of the Canadian tobacco settlement, a court-approved deal under which three tobacco companies pay C$32.5bn in total to settle decades of health claims. BAT made an upfront payment, and US tax timing went against it too. Neither repeats every year: in 2024, before the settlement, BAT made £7,901m. BAT expects about £50bn of free cash flow between 2024 and 2030 and had generated £14.2bn by June. That leaves about £35.8bn to find in four and a half years, or roughly £8bn a year.
If BAT delivers that, its dividend is covered 1.5 times. But compare what each claim rests on. Imperial's dividend is covered twice by cash it has already produced. BAT's is covered once by cash it has produced and 1.5 times by cash it forecasts.
Debt is the other difference. BAT's adjusted net debt was £31,969m at June, up from £30,416m in December, when it was 2.48 times EBITDA. It expects to be inside its 2.0 to 2.5 times range by the end of 2026. After the dividend there was no free cash left over the past twelve months, so this year's £1.3bn buyback is being paid for with borrowing. Adjusted net debt rose by about £1.6bn in the first half of 2026.
Why did BAT fall 3.95% on Tuesday? We could not find a company-specific reason, and we will not invent one. BAT made no announcement, the shares were not going ex-dividend, and we found no broker downgrade. What we can say is that consumer staples as a group fell 2.1% and health care 2.0%, both more than the index, as we show in our breakdown of the FTSE 100's fall. The fall took its yield from 5.2% to 5.4%.
Imperial Brands vs BAT: which is the better business?
BAT, because it has built a second business that makes money. Imperial is a cigarette company run for cash.
The industry calls vapes, heated tobacco and nicotine pouches "next generation products", "new categories" or "smoke-free". They are the only part of the market that is growing.
BAT's smoke-free business is about nine times the size of Imperial's on a yearly basis, and it is in profit
Imperial Brands
BAT
Smoke-free revenue
£419m (year to Sep 2026)
£1,928m (half year to Jun 2026)
Growth, stripping out exchange rate moves
+11.4%
+18.0%
Profit or loss
£63m loss
£257m profit before shared overheads
Share of revenue
4.9%
19.8%
Company target
Double-digit growth in 2027
Half of revenue by 2035
Cigarette volumes
−3.4% (stick equivalents)
−4.6% (half year)
Effect of prices and product mix
+5.1%
+6.8% (half year)
US share of profit
About 32%
About 57%
Source: Imperial Brands results for the year to 30 Sep 2026; BAT 2025 results and half-year report to 30 Jun 2026; Yield Theory calculation
BAT's smoke-free revenue for six months was 4.6 times Imperial's for a full year, so about nine times on a yearly basis. BAT's earned £257m of "category contribution", its measure of profit before shared overheads. Imperial's lost £63m. BAT wants these products to earn a margin of at least 30% by 2030 and to be half its revenue by 2035, targets it set at its capital markets day in September.
The volume rows are not like for like. Imperial counts "stick equivalents", which convert rolling tobacco and cigars into the cigarettes they would make, for a September year. BAT counts cigarettes for a calendar half. Read them as direction only: both are shrinking at 3% to 5% a year and both are raising prices faster than that.
The US line is a risk for BAT as much as a strength. It earned £6,543m of its £11,572m adjusted operating profit there in 2025, so one regulator and one legal system decide more than half its profit. Imperial earns about 32% of its tobacco profit in America.
How big a threat is tax and regulation?
Big enough to decide which markets shrink fastest. For Imperial, Germany is the one to watch. BAT's biggest exposure is the US, at about 46% of its first-half revenue.
Where cigarette volumes are falling fastest
Australia (Imperial's volume)−39.0%
UK (whole market)−16.5%
US (whole market)−5.2%
Germany (whole market)−4.1%
Imperial, all markets−3.4%
Imperial, Africa, Asia and Eastern Europe+1.5%
Change in the year to 30 September 2026, as reported by Imperial Brands. Whole-market figures are Imperial's estimates of industry volumes.
Source: Imperial Brands results for the year to 30 Sep 2026
Germany is Imperial's biggest European market at 13% of revenue. It passed a new tobacco tax law in October. The average pack of 20 rises from €8.05 to €9.10 in 2027, a 13% jump, and to €11.78 by 2030, according to figures reported by the dpa news agency. That is 46% in four years. Imperial has warned the first step will cost it up to £20m in 2027, a small sum against £4,130m of profit, but the tax rises three more times after that.
Elsewhere. Australia shows what can go wrong when tax makes a legal pack too expensive: Imperial's volumes there fell 39% in a year, and BAT said in its half-year report that illegal cigarettes are now around 80% of the market. It is only 1% of Imperial's revenue. The UK, 6% of revenue, shrank 16.5% on Imperial's estimate, and its Tobacco and Vapes Act bars sales to anyone born on or after 1 January 2009, so the legal age rises every year from 2027. EU finance ministers failed to agree higher minimum tobacco taxes on 9 November and will try again in December.
Are the shares cheap against history and peers?
Imperial is cheaper than BAT and the two big American tobacco companies on adjusted earnings, and cheaper than BAT on cash. On reported earnings the gap to BAT almost disappears, which is the main argument against our view.
The price to earnings ratio (P/E) is the share price divided by a year's earnings per share. We show it three ways. All use diluted earnings, which count shares owed to staff under share schemes: 338.7p for Imperial, a little below the 341.0p used for dividend cover.
Imperial Brands
BAT
Share price, 17 Nov
2,918p
4,524p
P/E on adjusted earnings
8.6 (338.7p)
12.8 (352.1p)
P/E on next year's adjusted earnings
8.0 (analysts' consensus)
12.3 (our estimate)
P/E on reported earnings
12.1 (241.3p)
13.0 (349.1p)
Free cash flow as a share of market value
12.0%
5.1%
The same, on each company's forward figure
10.0%
8.0%
Market value
about £22bn
about £99bn
Reported earnings include £327m of restructuring costs and a £313m legal charge, which are real money, and £338m of amortisation, an accounting charge for brands bought years ago that costs no cash. If you think Imperial will keep finding new "one-off" costs every year, use 12.1 and the shares are no bargain. We put more weight on the cash rows. Imperial turned 12.0% of its market value into free cash flow this year, after paying those restructuring and legal bills. BAT turned 5.1% of its value into cash over the past twelve months. Even if BAT hits the £8bn a year its plan needs, and Imperial only hits its floor, Imperial is still ahead at 10.0% against 8.0%.
Imperial's forward P/E uses the 363.9p of 2027 earnings in the analyst consensus Imperial publishes, compiled on 2 November. BAT's uses our estimate of 2026 earnings, about 367p: last year's 352.1p grown by 6.5%, the middle of BAT's guidance, less the 2% to 2.5% that BAT says currency will cost. So the two forward figures are not strictly like for like, and the market values are our estimates.
Why is Imperial this cheap? We see four reasons. Its cigarette volumes shrink every year. It has almost no smoke-free business to replace them. Its headline earnings have left out restructuring costs in each of the past two years. And it cut its dividend in 2020. We think a 12% cash return pays you for those risks.
Against history. Hargreaves Lansdown, using LSEG data, put BAT's ten-year average forward P/E at 10.0. Our 12.3 is about a quarter above that.
For Imperial we do not have a ten-year series we trust, so we use the past year. The shares traded between 2,408p and 3,632p, a P/E range of 7.1 to 10.7 on this year's adjusted earnings. At 8.6, Imperial sits in the lower half of that range and 20% below its high.
Against peers. The more smoke-free revenue a company has, the more investors pay for it.
Investors pay most for the tobacco companies furthest from cigarettes
Philip Morris International22.5x
Altria13.2x
BAT12.3x
Imperial Brands8.0x
Price divided by forecast adjusted earnings. Philip Morris and Altria are StockAnalysis figures for 16 and 17 November; BAT is our estimate and Imperial uses company-published consensus, both at the 17 November close. Other data providers show different US figures, so treat those two as approximate.
Source: StockAnalysis; Imperial Brands consensus, 2 Nov 2026; BAT guidance; Yield Theory calculation
Philip Morris International, maker of the Iqos heated tobacco device and Zyn pouches, gets more than 40% of its revenue from smoke-free products and trades at about 22 times forecast earnings, on StockAnalysis figures. Altria, which sells Marlboro in the US, trades at about 13 times.
What brokers think. Three of the five we found rate Imperial a buy. One has a target below the share price.
Broker
View on Imperial
Target
Against 2,918p
Goldman Sachs (2 Nov)
Buy
3,600p
+23%
Deutsche Bank (9 Oct)
Buy
3,500p
+20%
Barclays (13 Nov)
Buy
3,330p
+14%
JPMorgan (10 Nov)
Neutral
3,200p
+10%
Jefferies (17 Nov)
Hold
2,700p
−7%
The first four are the latest ratings before the results, as listed by TipRanks. Jefferies kept its view after them, saying the profit guidance beat expectations but currency would offset it, Proactive reported. Jefferies also noted that European volumes fell 7.8%, more than it expected; about half of that came from Imperial's own exit from private-label cigarettes, the cheap own-brand packs it made for retailers.
Do these dividends beat a gilt?
Barely. Imperial yields about 0.3 percentage points more than a 10-year gilt and BAT yields about the same as one.
A gilt is a UK government bond. The 10-year gilt yielded about 5.4% on Tuesday. The government pays that every year and returns your money at the end, though the price can move in between. A dividend can be cut and a share price can fall, so a share should offer more.
On £10,000 invested
Income in year one
Income in year five
What changes it
Imperial Brands
£571
£668
Dividend growth of 4% a year
BAT
£542
£587
Dividend growth of 2% a year
10-year gilt
£540
£540
Nothing: the payment is fixed
The year-five figures assume each company keeps raising its dividend at its latest rate, which nothing guarantees.
Tax changes the sums outside an ISA or pension. Dividends above the £500 allowance are taxed at 10.75% for basic-rate and 35.75% for higher-rate taxpayers, so a higher-rate taxpayer keeps a 3.7% yield from Imperial and 3.5% from BAT. Gilt interest is taxed as income too, but gains on gilts are free of capital gains tax, so a gilt bought below its face value keeps more of its return. Inside an ISA none of this applies. Our issue on insurer dividends against gilts works through the tax with an example, and our explainer on rising yields covers why gilts pay this much.
Bull, base and bear: what could each share return in three years?
In our base case both shares return about 38% over three years. In our bear case Imperial loses 14% and BAT 11%, even after dividends, and in our bull case Imperial returns 73% and BAT 60%. The difference in the base case is what each needs: Imperial's rests on cash it already makes, BAT's on a recovery in cash flow.
Imperial Brands
Bear
Base
Bull
EPS growth a year
−3%
6%
10%
Dividend growth a year
0%
4%
5%
EPS in 2029
309p
403p
451p
P/E at the end
6.5
8.6
10.0
Share price
2,009p
3,475p
4,508p
Dividends over three years
500p
541p
552p
Total return
−14%
+38%
+73%
BAT
Bear
Base
Bull
EPS growth a year
0%
6.5%
8%
Dividend growth a year
0%
2%
3%
EPS in 2029
367p
443p
462p
P/E at the end
9.0
12.3
14.0
Share price
3,304p
5,465p
6,474p
Dividends over three years
735p
765p
780p
Total return
−11%
+38%
+60%
Level in the base case; Imperial has more upside and a little more downside
Imperial BrandsBAT
−2020406080%0
−14%−11%
BearImperial Brands−14%BAT−11%
38%38%
BaseImperial Brands38%BAT38%
73%60%
BullImperial Brands73%BAT60%
BearBaseBull
Our estimated total return over three years: the change in share price plus dividends received, as a percentage of the 17 November share price.Source: Yield Theory estimates from company results and guidance
Both base cases come to about 11% a year. They are level partly because we cut Imperial's growth to the 6% its cash supports and left BAT at the middle of its guidance. If Imperial delivers the 8% it guides to, its base case rises to about 45%.
Imperial's bear case needs earnings per share to fall 3% a year, which could happen if German and UK volumes went the way of Australia's and the buyback was cut to protect the balance sheet. Its share price would end at 2,009p, a quarter below Jefferies' 2,700p target. BAT's bear case needs no fall in profit at all, only for investors to stop paying extra for smoke-free growth and for the P/E to drop below its ten-year average.
Neither bear case includes a dividend cut. Imperial has cut once, in 2020, when debt was 2.9 times EBITDA. At 2.0 times and with the dividend taking under 60% of free cash flow, we think a freeze is the realistic worst case within three years.
The bull case favours Imperial because it starts cheaper. A move from 8.6 to 10 times earnings is a small change in opinion. For BAT to reach 14 times, investors would have to value it closer to Philip Morris.
Which is the better tobacco share for income?
Imperial Brands, at these prices.
Pick Imperial Brands if you want the highest covered income and accept owning a shrinking business run for cash. You get a 5.7% yield growing 4% a year, a buyback retiring nearly 7% of the shares annually, and debt at the low end of the company's range. The drawback: almost nothing in smoke-free products, heavy exposure to Germany's tax rises, and earnings growth that depends on a buyback partly funded by debt.
Pick BAT if you want a tobacco company that may still be growing in 2035. You get a 27-year record of dividend increases and a smoke-free business that is in profit and growing 18%. The drawback: you pay 12.8 times earnings, the dividend grows 2% a year, and it took all of the past twelve months' free cash flow.
If you already own BAT, we would not sell it to buy Imperial on these numbers alone. Switching costs you 0.5% stamp duty and dealing fees, and BAT's dividend is not under threat. The case for Imperial is strongest for new money.
Own neither if a gilt at 5.4% does the job for you. Neither share pays much more today, and both can fall.
Key risks
Tax outruns pricing. Both companies assume volume declines of 3% to 5% a year that price rises can cover. A tax-led jump like Germany's leaves less room for their own increases.
The buyback slows. If Imperial's cash lands at the floor and it chooses not to borrow, earnings growth falls towards the 2% to 4% that profit alone delivers.
Litigation. Imperial took a £313m charge this year after losing a case in Delaware over payments on brands it bought in 2015. It has paid £150m and the rest falls due over three years. BAT is paying into the Canadian settlement and faces a US class action over Natural American Spirit that an appeals court allowed to proceed in July, according to Reuters.
Currency. Imperial expects exchange rates to cut 2027 revenue, profit and earnings per share by 0.5% to 1.5%. BAT expects a 2% to 2.5% hit to 2026 earnings per share.
Gilts. If the 10-year yield rises towards 6%, a 5.7% dividend looks less special and income shares tend to fall.
What would change our view
We would stop preferring Imperial if any of these happened:
It cut or paused the buyback, or let debt rise above 2.5 times EBITDA.
Free cash flow came in below the £2.2bn floor.
Volumes fell more than 5% in a year while price rises dropped below 4%.
Restructuring or legal charges of this size appeared again next year, which would make reported earnings the right basis and the shares fully priced.
We would switch to BAT if:
Its free cash flow covered the dividend at least 1.5 times over a full year, with debt below 2.3 times EBITDA.
The share price fell to about 3,770p, where the dividend yield would be 6.5%.
The smoke-free profit margin moved towards 20%, from 13.3% at the half year, which would show the 30% target is realistic.
When are the next dividends paid?
Payment
Buy before (ex-dividend date)
Paid
Imperial Brands
41.68p
26 November 2026
31 December 2026
Imperial Brands
41.68p
18 February 2027
31 March 2027
BAT
61.26p
24 December 2026
3 February 2027
To receive a dividend you must own the shares before the ex-dividend date. A share usually falls by about the size of the dividend on that day.
What to watch next
Dates that test the case for each share
26 NovImperial goes ex-dividend41.68p, paid 31 December
DecemberBAT trading updateWatch for a 2027 buyback
1 Jan 2027German tax rise; UK age-of-sale rule starts
11 Feb 2027BAT full-year resultsFree cash flow and debt ratio
May 2027Imperial half-year results (expected)German volumes after the tax rise
BAT announced its £1.3bn buyback for 2026 in last December's statement and has not yet announced one for 2027. A similar or larger figure would show confidence that cash flow is recovering. For Imperial, the first evidence on Germany arrives with the half-year results.
Our read
We would buy Imperial with new income money at 2,918p, and we would size it as a tobacco holding, not a bond substitute. We plan on 6% earnings growth, not the 8% it guides to.
The weakness in our case is that 8.6 times is a P/E on earnings before almost £1bn of costs. That is why we lean on cash flow, and why another year of large "one-off" charges would change our mind.
We would hold BAT but not add to it here. At 12.8 times earnings, with the dividend taking all the past year's free cash, you are paying for a recovery in cash flow before it has shown up. December's buyback decision and February's cash flow figure are the two numbers that would move us.
How we built this, and where it could be off
Sources: Imperial's full-year results of 17 November 2026, its March 2025 capital markets day statement and the analyst consensus it published on 2 November; BAT's 2025 results, half-year report of 30 July and capital markets day statement of 29 September; GOV.UK, dpa and Politico for tax and regulation.
Prices: closing quotes for 17 November from Hargreaves Lansdown, checked against Sharecast. The 52-week range is from Yahoo Finance. The 10-year gilt yield is a market quote of about 5.38%, not an official close.
Share counts and market values are our estimates: each company's dividend bill divided by its dividend per share, about 756 million shares for Imperial and 2.19 billion for BAT (the £5,238m BAT paid in 2025 divided by the 239.06p a share paid during that calendar year). They could be out by a percent or two.
Imperial estimates: the 2027 dividend payments, the £550m shortfall, the 6% growth figure and the year-end debt ratio are ours, and they assume the buyback is spread evenly through the year. The £181m shortfall in 2026 explains only part of the £380m rise in adjusted net debt; we have not reconciled the rest.
BAT: the 2.48 times debt ratio is from December 2025, because BAT did not publish one at the half year. Our 367p earnings estimate for 2026 is not BAT's figure. BAT also reports some measures "adjusted for Canada", which lowers 2025 earnings per share to 340.5p at constant currency; on that basis its P/E would be 13.3, not 12.8. Its reported earnings for 2025 were lifted by a change in its Canadian provision, so its reported P/E flatters it.
Second-hand figures: the US P/E figures come from one data provider and others differ. Broker targets are as listed by TipRanks and Proactive, not from the notes themselves. The German pack prices are from a news agency report of the law.
The scenario returns ignore tax, dealing costs and reinvested dividends. Data runs to the London close on 17 November 2026.
L&G yields 7.1% but only 1.8 points more than a gilt, with the thinnest cover of the big four. Aviva yields less than a gilt and is still our pick. The maths.
Barratt Redrow now combines two of Britain's biggest builders and still builds fewer homes than Barratt alone did before the pandemic, at half the margin. Here's what that means for Persimmon, Taylor Wimpey, Berkeley and Vistry shares.
The thesis, the numbers behind it, and what would break it. Full access is $39 a month.