Imperial Brands or BAT? The 5.7% Dividend After Up to 4,600 Job Cuts

· Members

Imperial Brands has the safer dividend, and at Tuesday's prices it is the tobacco share we would own for income. It yields 5.7%, covered 2.1 times by free cash flow. British American Tobacco (BAT) yields 5.4%, and its dividend took all its free cash flow.

Imperial is cheaper and its dividend is better covered; BAT is further ahead in smoke-free products
At the 17 Nov closeImperial BrandsBAT
Share price2,918p4,524p
Dividend yield5.7%5.4%
Price to adjusted earnings8.612.8
Times the dividend was covered by free cash flow2.1 (year to Sep 2026)1.0 (year to Jun 2026)
Net debt divided by a year's profit before interest, tax and depreciation (EBITDA)2.02.5 (Dec 2025)
Buyback as a share of market value6.8%1.3%
Latest dividend increase4.0%2.0%
Smoke-free share of revenue4.9%19.8%
Source: Imperial Brands results for the year to 30 Sep 2026; BAT results for 2025 and the half year to 30 Jun 2026; Hargreaves Lansdown closing prices; Yield Theory calculations

Free cash flow is the cash left after running the business. Imperial's covered its dividend 2.1 times last year, and its shares cost 8.6 times adjusted earnings. BAT's shares cost 12.8 times earnings, and its dividend took all the free cash flow it made over the past twelve months.

We do not expect Imperial to return more than BAT. Our base case is about 38% over three years for both. The difference is what each return rests on: Imperial's on cash it has already made, BAT's on a recovery in cash flow that has not shown up yet. The catch with Imperial is its £1.5bn-a-year share buyback. If cash comes in at the bottom of its guidance, a fifth of next year's payout will be borrowed, which puts the buyback, and about two points of earnings growth, at risk before the dividend.

The two companies report on different calendars: Imperial's figures are for the year to September 2026, BAT's dividend and earnings are for calendar 2025, and its cash flow is for the twelve months to June 2026. Imperial's 8.6 is on earnings before almost £1bn of restructuring, legal and accounting charges. On earnings after them it is 12.1, which we come back to under valuation.

Imperial reported full-year results on Tuesday 17 November. It raised its dividend 4%, promised another £1.5bn of share buybacks, and confirmed job cuts that the Guardian and others added up to 4,600: 2,100 already decided and up to 2,500 more by 2030. The shares fell 1.98% on a day the FTSE 100 fell 1.76%. BAT said nothing and fell 3.95%.

Is the Imperial Brands dividend safe?

Yes. Profit or cash covers it between 1.5 and 2.1 times, depending on the measure.

"Cover" is how many times a company could pay its dividend out of profit or cash. As a rule of thumb, 1.5 times or more leaves room for a bad year. Below 1.0 the company is paying out more than it makes.

Adjusted earnings leave out costs the company treats as one-offs, which came to almost £1bn this year. Reported earnings include everything. We come back to that gap below.

Cover measureCalculationCover
Adjusted earnings per share341.0p divided by 166.72p2.0 times
Reported earnings per share242.9p divided by 166.72p1.5 times
Free cash flow, 2026£2,636m divided by £1,269m2.1 times
Free cash flow, 2027 guidance floor£2,200m divided by about £1,250m1.8 times

Even if free cash flow lands at the bottom of Imperial's guidance, the dividend takes 57% of it. The £1,250m for next year's dividend payments is our estimate.

The total cost of the dividend fell, from £1,314m to £1,269m, even though the payment per share rose 4.0%. That is because Imperial bought back and cancelled 52.5 million shares, 6.5% of those in issue at the start of the year. A company that raises its dividend 4% and shrinks its share count faster than that pays less in total each year. Imperial could keep this up with no profit growth at all, for as long as it can fund the buyback.

Imperial has cut before. In May 2020 it reduced the dividend by a third to pay down debt, as interactive investor reported at the time. Today's 166.72p is still 19% below the 206.6p paid for 2019.

Imperial cut its dividend by a third in 2020; BAT has raised its payout every year
100125150175200225250p2016201820202021202220242026206.6pCut by a third166.72p166.7pImperial Brands245.0pBAT2016155.2p169.4p2017170.7p195.2p2018187.8p203.0p2019206.6p210.4p2020137.7p215.6p2021139.1p217.8p2022141.2p230.9p2023146.8p235.5p2024153.4p240.2p2025160.3p245.0p2026166.7p
Dividend per share declared for each financial year. Imperial's year ends in September and BAT's in December, so BAT has not yet declared a 2026 dividend.Source: Imperial Brands and BAT annual results

Companies in this article

Keep reading

Members-only research

Members are reading this

The thesis, the numbers behind it, and what would break it. Full access is $39 a month.

Read the full research

Get a full issue free

Enter your email and we'll send you a complete Yield Theory issue, then the opening of each new one. Unsubscribe anytime.